Nigel Megitt

@chaals your suggestion means that if around half the members are recused then the formal objection can never be sustained, because the supermajority cannot be achieved. Is that what you...

> If the council reaches consensus, it isn't an issue. If they are too small to be viable, the current draft says they should be dissolved and a new council...

Correct presentation in this case depends on the subtitle format and data. Can you provide the source subtitle file?

Related data point: Overlapping regions and therefore text is permitted by the specification in generic TTML, but not in the IMSC or EBU-TT-D profiles that are commonly used for subtitles...

Recognition?

@mnot I read it that way too. There seems to be a grey area where something that would ordinarily be called a decision is being made, but there's no group...

I don't believe there's adequate motivation for this change, as detailed at https://github.com/w3c/w3process/issues/653#issuecomment-1280922863 and we should not make it without thinking through the risks and overall approach more clearly.

This does not match my understanding: 1. A Proposal is raised. 2. An opportunity to assess consensus for the Proposal occurs. 3. Formal objections to the _Proposal_ can be raised....

I can't find it now, but I think I made a comment that I thought that wording was wrong, at some point...

> a "decision" seems a process itself hidden in each WG's [decision policy](https://github.com/w3c/w3process/issues/425#issuecomment-1185582916) I take the WG's decision policy to be additional practice on top of whatever the Process says....