Results 844 comments of Francisco Giordano

Thank you @GrandSchtroumpf. I'm noticing that the API docs are no longer present in the deploy preview that was generated for this PR and I'm not sure what's causing it...

Following up, I still don't understand why the API docs are no longer present so we can't merge this. I don't have a lot of time to look into this...

There are many EIPs for `transferAndCall` functionality. Why should we implement this one? I can see that the EIP is Final but it looks like there was zero discussion about...

@lukehutch Your comments sound like you're angry about things. I recommend reviewing your approach to the conversation. This is a place for constructive discussion.

I honestly don't see anything in the EIP that strongly indicates `transferAndCall` should revert when the destination is not a contract. @lukehutch You mentioned that the spec says transferring to...

I meant external function calls like `target.foo()` revert if the target is not a contract.

I really don't think the behavior of the function with EOA receivers is such an important issue. The important bit in this EIP is the addition of a callback for...

In #3525 it was pointed out that the interface should be moved from the interfaces directory and be located next to the implementation. What do you think?

I imagine this parameter is proposed as a way to catch, before it is proposed, a proposal that will be too big to execute. However, a proposal might be too...

Can you explain the importance of burning for NFTs? Why would we recommend that devs "must" implement a burn function? The way we see it burning is a feature that...