David Singer

Results 390 comments of David Singer

Indeed, are two implementations that don't share code, were written by different engineers, but are from the same company, 'independent'? (We have this case in WebVTT). If the same consultant...

I believe that Wendy maintained, and the process CG agreed, that defining 'independent' clearly in the process would be hard, and take too much text. But indeed somewhere we need...

I'm fine with leaving this open until such time as we understand how/where this is documented and defined. re-opening.

We should look at improving /Guide, probably in , to give guidance without setting rules. It's too situational for rules, but advice on such questions as: * are two implementations,...

+1 to Jeff. This is a (major) reason for AC review. Whether the AC can see what comment HR groups, TAG, AB, and (for charters offered by other than the...

Mike, in a member-led consortium, for that is what we are and formally becoming, it's the members' responsibility. We can't duck it, and we shouldn't delegate it either. We elect...

> a large number of the "philosophical objections" I have seen over the last couple of decades and more are just ill-disguised efforts to tilt the market in one direction...

Let's leave this hanging. Once the ODC (or something like it) is approved, we can tell if that causes any cleanup, and if we change the process so that the...

Currently defined in the draft Process that the Council explicitly includes the CEO. Close?

we have simplified this to being a team appointment with prior consultation