David Singer
David Singer
I think in the process re-write, we're saying that the AC can appeal "any decision". An AC appeal seems awfully heavy for objecting to a chair choice, and humiliating for...
Noted that this seems orthogonal to director-free; request to move this to the general process.
It should be clear that making public, formal, complaints, about specific people (chairs) should be very much a last resort, and that more discreet methods should be tried first (talk...
Let's see if I can clear up. a) Yes, any formal decision can have a formal objection. b) The recourse process if you don't like a chair appointment is (a)...
(see the Process Call logs for July 24th 2019, probably https://www.w3.org/2019/07/24-w3process-minutes.html)
(we expect to clean this up as part of the Director-free rewrite)
florian: Came out of Director-free discussion ... but was a broader topic ... Not clear right now it's not clear if possible to object to change in chair if done...
it's the decisions represented in the announcement; that X is being removed, that Y is appointed, as chair.
@cwilso I think that's the essence of this issue. We're not sure; can you FO or appeal a chair appointment? It appears to be a 'decision' but it's not defined...
Yes, there are a bunch of decisions (which result in announcements) where it's unclear both * whether one can object * and if so, how, or what the correct course...