David Singer
David Singer
OK, I wasn't clear. I meant "making a decision different from what the team advised", not "making a decision different on the original question."
The short answer to the posed question is "whatever the Director could decide today". The ODC is a slide-in replacement for the Director, takes the same advice and support, and...
Ok, sorry to be dense. So you are saying that we restrict the possible outcomes to (a) After discussion, a harmonious solution is found and the FO is withdrawn without...
So, this rules out "partially sustained", for example. If the FO objects to something in principle and says "and therefore if this FO is sustained, we do X, Y, and...
Perhaps we can deal with @frivoal 's concern by simply stating that the ODC's decision is strictly scoped to the FO and the decision or action being objected to. Guys,...
@frivoal 1. I think you are mixing "advice" and "decision". The council (Director today) issues a decision. If the group et al. don't abide by that decision, then we have...
we need to (a) verify that we believe a binary ruling (uphold the decision, or uphold the objection and un-make the decision) is always possible and (b) that there have...
@chaals do you mean the hypothetical in https://github.com/w3c/w3process/issues/279#issuecomment-520510739 or https://github.com/w3c/w3process/issues/279#issuecomment-494863182, and in either case, what would the hypothetical decision and FO be?
@fantasai You're right; the the scenario then is * something is in a CR and has been for a while, no-one objects * I discover a problem, and ask that...