Brent Shaffer

For anyone blocked by this bug, you can rollback to `grpc-1.49.0` to get around the issue until there is a fix (here's an example in [github actions](https://github.com/googleapis/google-cloud-php/pull/5696/files))

Can we get an update on this? We are still pinned to `grpc-1.49.0` in our tests, which causes each test to run 20+ minutes slower because it has to install...

I can confirm these issues have been fixed in `1.54.0`, and pinning to this version plus [implementing workflow caching](https://github.com/googleapis/google-cloud-php/pull/5944/files#diff-95557d53bf91069e59d82b9d8fcfaf52ec84a762858983edd5ef3c9b3e4c8191R28-R40) has fixed the issue for us.

I haven't tested in later versions, no, but I would think that the chance of a regression in a minor version is slim.

As indicated by the breaking change detector, we have a bunch of RPC method parameters which were changed from required to optional: - `BigtableClient#checkAndMutateRow()` - `BigtableClient#mutateRow()` - `BigtableClient#mutateRows()` - `BigtableClient#readModifyWriteRow()`...

The "problem" is that there is no indication in the protos that "document.id" is required in the [DiscoveryEngine protos](https://github.com/googleapis/googleapis/blob/a17ce769d068601f2293cb34a58d7c26e382fa99/google/cloud/discoveryengine/v1/document.proto#L100). Without this, our automatically generated samples don't know that we need...

Discussed offline but to summarize, these are separate classes. Let me try to explain better: - The class `Google\Analytics\Data\V1beta\BetaAnalyticsDataClient` is deprecated, and it extends `Google\Analytics\Data\V1beta\Gapic\BetaAnalyticsDataClient`. Both of these classes are...

We do not currently support batch functionality in this library, but it's a feature we have considered, and is likely on it's way! Thank you for the suggestion.

I don't understand the request here, and the context link is not helpful either. Can you explain more what the objective is here?

I think this is outdated. We now use `@see` tags, which are helpful for IDEs and also for our documentation at cloud.google.com/php/docs/reference. I do not think there's anything else that...