Bill Duncan

Results 515 comments of Bill Duncan

@zhengj2007 COB defines agent role as: ``` A role realized by a participant in a process such that the participant causes the process. ``` This seems okay to me. However,...

@zhengj2007 @ddooley This issue has gotten far away from why I opened it, which as to remove the property chain `realizes o concretizes` from `executes`.

@zhengj2007 Yes. I realize that is the intent of the property chain `realizes o concretizes`. However, myself (and some others) think that the notion of realizing the concretization of an...

@zhengj2007 I am quite familiar with the notion of ICEs being concretized as either a quality or realizable. Concretizations as qualities makes an intuitive appeal that we (and machines) understand/process...

@alanruttenberg Hah! Not going down that rabbit hole :)

I'm not advocating the notion of realizable concretizations. So, I don't follow why I have to give some account of how realizables are created. I've already gave a thumbnail account...

Also > Well, absent an articulation of how your intuition works we just have a vague notion there might be a problem and it's a mystery (at least to me)...

Thanks @zhengj2007 I opened the ticket b/c I think the property chain should be dropped.

@ddooley > is the issue that an ICE like a protocol or programming code, by itself is not concretized into a realizable? Yes. This is the issue. I don't think...

> It's in OBI and has been for 10 years. It's not going anywhere and while it doesn't make sense to Bill, it makes sense to a bunch other of...