Kelsey Gilbert comments

Results 396 comments of


                                            Kelsey Gilbert

Criteria for pushing the WebGPU and WGSL specification to Candidate Recommendation

WGSL meeting minutes 2022-07-06 * KG: last week we said "think about it". Thoughts? Don't have to make decisions now. * KG: in my mind - we're kind of at...

Specification needs to clarify behavior of indexing of abstract composite type with runtime value

WGSL 2022-09-06 Minutes * KG: Feels editorial but technically a change? Recommendation from BC that we materialize the index before doing the index. * BC: Don't think there is much...

createPipelineAsync() doesn't reject its promise, even if the created pipeline is invalid

GPU Web 2022-09-07/08 APAC-timed * MM: if you use createPipelineAsync you get a Promise, and it's resolved even if it's a compile failure. Might expect rejection in that case because...

createPipelineAsync() doesn't reject its promise, even if the created pipeline is invalid

I kind of don't see much point in drawing a strong distinction between reportReady: true vs false. Why not always provide a .ready promise, always plan to do it async,...

createPipelineAsync() doesn't reject its promise, even if the created pipeline is invalid

GPU Web 2022-10-05 * KN: KG, the plan was for you to put together a proposal. * KG: one more week please. * CW: we can wait another week but...

createPipelineAsync() doesn't reject its promise, even if the created pipeline is invalid

GPU Web Meeting 2022-10-12/13 APAC-timed * JB: general agreement that sync/async distinction isn't great indicator about pipeline creation on-thread vs. off-thread * JB: browser can always take one or the...

invalid expressions in const-expr and override-expr should be error (no later than pipeline creation time)

WGSL meeting minutes 2022-08-02 * JB: Seems consensus on making the out-of-bounds case should be such an error. * JB: When you have an inconsistency and one of the alternatives...

invalid expressions in const-expr and override-expr should be error (no later than pipeline creation time)

WGSL 2022-08-09 Minutes * JB: Substituted one problematic criteria for another one. We defined how out of bounds works, so we can’t say this is how wgsl works to define...

invalid expressions in const-expr and override-expr should be error (no later than pipeline creation time)

WGSL 2022-08-16 Minutes * MM: In discussions, runtime is more important then compile time behaviour. Think the compile time behavour is dependant on runtime. Compile time behaviour depends on runtime...

invalid expressions in const-expr and override-expr should be error (no later than pipeline creation time)

WGSL 2022-08-23 Minutes * KG: Talked about domains of builtins. Feels like we’ve strayed from path. Agree we have to solve these things, worry we’re dealing with what we need...