Giuseppe Natale

Thank you for this analysis, it's encompassing and synthesizing a lot of the context of what is happening, making it more clear and digestible as a single document, in a...

> Minor corrections and formatting. In many places, the token of AtomOne is referred to as ATOM/ATOMs, If not intended, it should be changed to ATONE/ATONEs. Can you reply with...

I think the right block is either [18010660](https://www.mintscan.io/cosmos/block/18010660) (where the tallying is completed, you can see it because of the delay with the previous block is over 2 minutes instead...

So for proposal 82, if we also want to snapshot the data for that one, it would be either block [12842181](https://www.mintscan.io/cosmos/block/12842181) - where the tally is triggered - or [12842182](https://www.mintscan.io/cosmos/block/12842182)...

Yeah you can see also that votes in both blocks that are for the respective proposal fail because "proposal is inactive", therefore I agree that those blocks are sufficient.

the blocks we decided to use are just before the tally, but after voting period has ended. If you see votes coming at that block fail as I have written...

> * Initially, let's involve only those who are pure/true NOers (NO + NoWithVeto). I think weighted vote are to be considered "pure" on the percentage that is assigned to...

Good question. I think we **definitely** need a constitution so it's a good starting point. I think some things are actually taken from that if I am not mistaken, but...

I'm of the opinion this would go somewhat agains the spirit of the initiative. Right now the only ICS provider is the Cosmos Hub. Renting security from the chain we...

> i think the proof-of-stake aspect is good enough for security as is. Many questions left unanswered, like how do we ensure that validators can grow from 0 to 1;...