Daniel Huppmann

This proposed variable seems to be a duplicate of "Carbon Capture|Utilization|Materials|*". And "Carbon Removal|*" describes "Gross removals of carbon dioxide (CO2) from atmospheric origin or biomass through deliberate human activities"...

@gunnar-pik, I'm confused about your comment regarding energy-efficiency investment - this is not part of this PR. Should I go ahead and merge the two variables in this PR: forestry-investment...

Thank you @kriegler100, pinging @IAMconsortium/common-definitions-emissions and @IAMconsortium/common-definitions-land for comment

Implement in #208 for carbon removal and carbon capture. There is still use of "Bioenergy" in "Agricultural Demand|Crops|Bioenergy" - should that also be revised?

Harmonized in carbon management variables via #208, keeping as is for bioenergy crops.

Thanks for the PR! Looks like the legacy-test is failing is because the unit's are ordered differently ``` model scenario region variable unit year model_a scen_a World GNP/P USD *...

For background, we initially had multiple levels to support different levels of detail for different species. Last week, @volker-krey said he preferred to have all possible combinations of species and...

We initially had this as all CO2, but changed for consistency with previous projects, see https://github.com/IAMconsortium/common-definitions/pull/113. It would be good to have clarity, but please do that as a separate...

@phackstock @gunnar-pik @Renato-Rodrigues @orichters @robertpietzcker - please let me know if this is a useful step towards automated validation of scenario submissions...

Thanks @orichters, yes, I've seen your format before and we want to develop in this direction too (and I hope that the yaml file is less heavy and more reliable...