Samuel Bosshardt comments

Results 6 comments of


                                            Samuel Bosshardt

Cannot resolve MX record on mailserver container (but host VM can)

Hi @Carazyda, Thanks for the troubleshooting questions. Prior to your comment, I found a workaround and am able to send and receive test messages. I tried the steps in the...

does DKIM verify that it actually went to Hunter?

> And looks like it is not even send to hunter. :clap: :clap: :clap: I'm not 100% convinced that it didn't actually get sent. I don't have access to Hunter's...

does DKIM verify that it actually went to Hunter?

> I don't see why you think SMTP servers shouldn't allow what I described. It happens every time you BCC someone! I disagree. BCC is a red herring in my...

does DKIM verify that it actually went to Hunter?

> DKIM doesn't protect the smtp transaction instructions just the contents of the message. Obviously DKIM does not sign the user's original SMTP headers. The user has authenticated to Gmail....

does DKIM verify that it actually went to Hunter?

I'm not sure which of my specific remarks your "because" is in response to. You are basically paraphrasing [what you'd said previously](https://github.com/robertdavidgraham/hunter-dkim/issues/9#issuecomment-721359589). I'd [previously responded](https://github.com/robertdavidgraham/hunter-dkim/issues/9#issuecomment-721379315) as to why I think...

does DKIM verify that it actually went to Hunter?

> argue with the people that wrote the SMTP RFCs I disagree with this (dismissive) recommendation. What I've said has little to do with SMTP RFCs. I never claimed that...