Rusty Russell

Results 308 comments of Rusty Russell

Rebased again, with more quantity_max requirement tweaks thanks to @jkczyz

I also proposed the "give the funding_key" to @cdecker but I wasn't sure anyone would be comfortable with it....

Yes, this is wrong. It's in bolt 7 because there was a desire to thin out bolt 2. It's not "independent of particular channels", its only relation to gossip is...

You can't just self-assign MIME types. There's actually a process for this; and you refer to the document which tells you that. The only no-registered name I can see would...

This was actually assigned at the IRC meeting: | Bits | Name |Description |------|-------------------|--------------- | 8/9 | `option_variable_onion` | Supports new onion format a-la #619 |

This was assigned at the IRC meeting: | Bits | Name |Description |------|-------------------|--------------- | 10/11 | `option_extended_gossip_queries` | Supports flags/checksums/timestamps a-la #557 |

I don't think any implementer reading this will know how to implement it; it is too loose on requirements, and risks channel breakage as a result. Ideally, Alice wants to...

You can't force people to do something sane, but we specify that they *should*. shrug...

OK, many tweaks to wording, but in particular: - No more minimum_depth; after 6 we ack the splice. That fits well with gossip, since we only have 10 blocks before...

OK, I reworked this on top of quiescence, and dropped the deterministic points which I am no longer convinced by.