geometry2 icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
geometry2 copied to clipboard

tf2: Standardize a convention to replace the tf_prefix API

Open jbohren opened this issue 11 years ago • 4 comments

The migration guide leaves this as a "longer term solution" but I think there are a lot of people who use and rely on tf_prefix for multi-robot (even single-master) systems, like modular robots. I think having a way to scope a node, or a component, or a namespace to a specific TF namespace is too common a problem to leave to each individual application.

jbohren avatar Oct 21 '13 13:10 jbohren

Are there any ideas how this should look like?

The tf2 design page still mentions tf_prefix as the solution for multiple robots. It later contradicts this by stating that tf_prefix has been removed.

NikolausDemmel avatar Jan 28 '16 16:01 NikolausDemmel

Just wondering if there has been any update or workaround for this? I am dealing with a multi-robot simulation that implements moveit, and I came across this issue on moveit's repository which is caused by the deprecation of tf_prefix.

ghost avatar Aug 31 '18 19:08 ghost

Any updates on a replacement? Since tf was deprecated it seems there is no way to apply a prefix from a launchfile and instead it has to be manually added in the code?

Toms42 avatar Feb 03 '20 07:02 Toms42

Has anybody given further thought to this?

agoeckner avatar Jul 06 '23 17:07 agoeckner