godel icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
godel copied to clipboard

Status of Godel Project?

Open melvinma opened this issue 5 years ago • 4 comments

It appears that this project has been inactive for half a year now. Could someone summarize what is going on? Milestone 4 achieved and no further plan? Anything else a new comer needs to know? Thanks.

melvinma avatar Sep 13 '18 16:09 melvinma

This is how I was able to successfully compile this code. I have NOT thoroughly test the codes yet.

original:
     git: {local-name: descartes, uri: 'https://github.com/Jmeyer1292/descartes.git', version: godel_refactor_omp}
new:
     git: {local-name: descartes, uri: 'https://github.com/ros-industrial-consortium/descartes.git', version: kinetic_devel}
  • need to change at least two files because of Descartes change in the new source -
file: descartes/descartes_planner/include/descartes_planner/ladder_graph_dag_search.h
         original:  double run();
         new:       double run(const std::vector<double>& seed_weights = {});
file: descartes/descartes_planner/src/ladder_graph_dag_search.cpp
         replace funtion run() to run(const std::vector<double>& seed_weights) 
         from    https://github.com/Jmeyer1292/descartes/blob/godel_refactor_omp/descartes_planner/src/ladder_graph_dag_search.cpp

melvinma avatar Sep 15 '18 16:09 melvinma

Thanks for your inquiry. Godel is still of interest and we are working scope and interested parties for M5. We are also pointing other parties to this repository for additional leverage, so hopefully something will happen on that front. Unfortunately we cannot be very deterministic on timing, but rest assured, things are happening!

robinsonmm avatar Sep 19 '18 17:09 robinsonmm

We are also interested in the status of this project. Based on the activity in the repo, it looks like there aren't people working on this any more. Based on the messages above from @melvinma , we were able to build the project. We might want to use it in a ROS training. However, we would like to use ROS Melodic for that. Are there plans to port the project to Melodic?

wilcobonestroo avatar Mar 31 '20 17:03 wilcobonestroo

I'm not aware of any direct plans to port it to Melodic as of today.

However, several forks seem to include the necessary changes already.

If you're after seeing what changes would be necessary, comparing those forks with this repository would seem sufficient.

If you're wondering whether godel will see future development (ie; is not a 'dead project'), that I can't say at this point in time.

gavanderhoorn avatar Apr 06 '20 12:04 gavanderhoorn