Martin Kouba

> > Not true - see [Jakarta EE Core Profile](https://jakarta.ee/specifications/coreprofile/10/jakarta-coreprofile-spec-10.0.html#target-and-rationale-for-the-core-profile). > > So I must understand "not true, you are right"? This link does not help at all any user...

>> This has been refuted many times. It is not possible to run Portable Extensions at build time because > Please stop writing that, it works and is used. It...

> graalvm is more or less the same case, only difference is graalvm enforces you to become build time for part of the process whereas other cases (java) do not...

> > Your other suggestion to require extension authors to correctly serialize their state is a recipe for disaster frankly (how do you serialize a client proxy to JSON?) >...

> It is clear from the examples in the specification, as well as from tests in the TCK,... See also the related https://issues.redhat.com/browse/CDITCK-416 and https://issues.redhat.com/browse/WELD-1740. > However, we shouldn't really...

> @mkouba The CDITCK project isn't visible anymore. It would be great if it could become visible again, because it has a lot of history and discussions. Does it still...

FTR `CDI.get(Class type)` would not be enough. You would also need `CDI.get(TypeLiteral type)` to select generic types. Actually, you would need to add the `Annotation... qualifiers` parameter as well. In...

I'd like to point out that **bean name != EL value expression**. It's a _period-separated list of valid EL identifiers_; which implies that the provided `ELResolver` must be able to...

> and if `magic.golden` has a property `fish` spec is clear that it must work (EL) but it will not behave as expected when you will resolve your produced string...

> @mkouba just said the intent is to not support hierarchical names FTR I did not say this, I merely said that I think that dots should not be used...