Kyℓe Hensel

this sounds like a problem with the import methodology. In [other countries](https://github.com/osm-nz/linz-address-import) the regular import & conflation process respects the improvements that other mappers have made, instead of blindly overwriting...

"public" might be a misleading label, since these facilities are often restricted to [`customers`](https://osm.wiki/Tag:access=customers) or [`private`](https://osm.wiki/Tag:access=private). So perhaps "Communal Kitchen" is better?

> Is it supposed to be used also for marinas where small pleasure craft berths? yeah that's possible > Also, wiki infobox restricts it to > > A **named** or...

thinking about a long term solution: maybe when you change presets from `A` to `B`, iD should remove all tags from preset `A` that are not in preset `B`. For...

yeah, the logic is [`autoSuggestions != false`](https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/blob/3704a006c3bf2b4356d737f52fd26f3016cbbb4c/modules/ui/fields/combo.js#L30) and [`type = combo|multiCombo|networkCombo|semiCombo|typeCombo`](https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/blob/3704a006c3bf2b4356d737f52fd26f3016cbbb4c/modules/ui/fields/index.js#L65-L89)

This preset was intentionally made unsearchable 10 years ago in f549e289cfdc3edafb3f031c1ae7c7a147be0f5f. At the time, [the wiki page seemed to suggest u](https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/w/index.php?title=Tag:barrier%3Dentrance&oldid=831521)sing `entrance=*` instead of `barrier=entrance`

just to be clear, I'm not a maintainer of iD. In https://github.com/openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema/issues/1471 I just wanted to provide some background information. It will be up to @tyrasd to make a decision

should iD also treat this tag as a routable highway type? ([Here's an example warning from iD](https://osm.org/way/1452822348)) which feels weird, but maybe it's expected

> where you mark it as a routable highway type? there's actually 6 different files that _might_ need tweaking, https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/pull/9633 is a good reference; the same change was made for...

the schema allows arbitrary translatable strings to be defined, not just `strings.placeholders`. For example, [the `access` field uses `strings.types`](https://github.com/openstreetmap/id-tagging-schema/blob/b22bc0/data/fields/access.json#L15-L22). See https://github.com/ideditor/schema-builder/pull/229 for the exact schema that's allowed. Therefore, this could...