Jason Desrosiers

Thanks for the correction Julian! It's been a while since I've written Python and didn't remember that correctly. That means that Python's `None` is equivalent to JSON's `null`. In that...

I think the discussion here has wound down and I don't think there's any action we need to take here, so I'm closing.

> Is it legal to use a non-canonical identifier in a `$schema` keyword to refer to a metaschema? The semantics for non-canonical identifiers is effectively implementation defined. Therefore, I think...

My thoughts on Karen's list > - a metaschema (a schema resource that another schema may wish to reference in a $schema keyword) MUST have an $id keyword I don't...

> I tried putting this together and couldn't get it to work out Good point! We'd need to give it an `$id` for it to work. In which case, we...

> I don't think that not knowing the dialect because you don't know how to interpret `$schema` (or to interpret it at all) is a valid argument. That wasn't what...

`$vocabulary` is what defines a dialect. `$schema` just identifies a schema that has the `$vocabulary` keyword. Since `$vocabulary` is always at the root of the schema, the fragment is meaningless...

You're right. I wasn't thinking about that. Then maybe it's just best to say fragments are undefined for dialect determination. That effectively means, don't use fragments, but also leaves things...

> can someone verify, please? That text hasn't changed. The issue still exists.

Hi, @riyap03. Thanks for showing your interest in this proposal. The first step for something like this is to get enough people showing interest to convince us that it's worth...