Christoph Hormann

This is addressed by #4978 - follow-up issues, like the matter of preprocessing the layer column, are organized in #5027.

Numbers: * `climbing=boulder`: 1002 uses (660 on nodes) - about 700 in combination with a `natural` tag. * `climbing=route_bottom`: 14k uses, a substantial number of those from an import/organized edit...

3800 uses https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:amenity%3Danimal_shelter

Sorry for the brevity - this was just providing data for future reference.

Nothing blocks this issue, it is open, arguments for or against rendering this are welcome as is discussion how rendering this tag could be implemented. Keep in mind however that:...

My assessment of the de facto meaning of the tag as given in https://github.com/gravitystorm/openstreetmap-carto/issues/4260#issuecomment-1033161440 is from an analysis of the data. Below a few examples of uses of the tag...

Yes, and it could be worth trying if such a concept could work also in combination with our base design for shelter/hut symbols.

Again - as i said previously several times - past bad decisions are neither a good reason nor an excuse to perpetuate bad design or cultural imperialism. I have pointed...

This looks right at a quick read and i would not mind adding this to the code. The most useful documentation otherwise about the road layers is probably what i...

Similar arguments against this as for ATMs in https://github.com/gravitystorm/openstreetmap-carto/issues/4575#issuecomment-1158651857. `amenity=charging_station` has `operator` tagged more than four times as frequently as `brand`. Of the examples on the wiki page for the...