David A. Harding

Agree it could be improved. FYI, the reason the example uses CMS is that it's meant to mirror as closely as possible the earlier example in the chapter where `OP_IF`...

> IMO a `.well-known` path would be better. Among things that use internet identifiers, Mastodon, Nostr, and Lightning all use `.well-known` paths. Only email and Bluesky use DNS records. Resolving...

@alexgleason > for DNS you'll need to add a new library and learn how to use it. It's less developer friendly. Sure. I think it's a tradeoff between that and...

I think there's a lot of advantage to updating even final BIPs with information about how those specifications are being widely used in practice, i.e. ` bitcoinaddress = *base58 /...

@TheBlueMatt > the back-and-forth there is a great example of why defining some new BIP just to suggest where to put new payment instructions in BIP 21s is going to...

@TheBlueMatt > my above claim is that there isn't any (more) difference of opinion :) I don't see the resolution to the discussion about bare keys vs key/values above, so...

@TheBlueMatt > The point of a BIP is to have the information people need to implement it in one convenient place. That's certainly ideal. However, I think in the case...

836ef064e433721238f0cddbf95da4b8c0ebe2b9 LGTM (obviously needs BIP # assigned and to be added to the index)

That does look like an error, probably the result of confusing difficulty (which increases as it gets harder) with target (which decreases as it gets harder). Thanks!

@gmaxwell > The logo should remain orange. This change would inadvertently play into efforts to create a false equivalence between Bitcoin and various fraudulent clones. Is it your desire that...