geocompr icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
geocompr copied to clipboard

Ch11

Open Lvulis opened this issue 2 years ago • 4 comments

A small fix and a possible inclusion for chapter 11 - I accidentally committed the fix into #838 but perhaps can work itself into a separate PR as that one has some repetition with what @Nowosad has done already in the branch updating to tmapv4

  • For the section on conventions one thing that naturally comes to mind when reading this is talking about a style guide such as the tidyverse style guide which sets out a consistent style for how code should be written. Since this book relies on tidyverse notation and functionality the tidyverse guide seems appropriate. The relevant parts of the tidyverse style guide for the target audience (introductory R and GIS users) are section 1 and section 2.
  • The code/11-x functions are all referred to by old chapter numbers, replaced and attaching PR.

Lvulis avatar Jul 21 '22 22:07 Lvulis

Regarding conventions -- @Robinlovelace will reply here as the primary chapter author.

@Lvulis can you prepare a separate PR for this chapter?

Nowosad avatar Jul 27 '22 09:07 Nowosad

Sure, is the idea for the new PR to include the commit fixing the code/11-x references? I ask as I am unfamiliar with how to structure the new PR to only take the commit associated with that and not include other commits that are in #838. Would it require creating a branch just for the C11 edits?

Not too much experience with GH for this! Sorry.

Lvulis avatar Jul 27 '22 19:07 Lvulis

Sure, is the idea for the new PR to include the commit fixing the code/11-x references?

Yes please, I looked at #838 again and see you have made some changes to Chapter 9 in that PR. It will make our life easier if you put in 2 separate PRs, one of each chapter.

Robinlovelace avatar Jul 27 '22 21:07 Robinlovelace

I plan to review this chapter.

Robinlovelace avatar Aug 23 '22 10:08 Robinlovelace

@Robinlovelace close?

Nowosad avatar Feb 09 '23 17:02 Nowosad

Yep, superseded by #919

Robinlovelace avatar Feb 14 '23 07:02 Robinlovelace