MetaGPT
MetaGPT copied to clipboard
geekan
Issues related with write_code_review and Total running cost
Bug description
- The Engineer Agent decided to rewrite the code after QA Engineer reported LGTM (It shows no issue in QAE's report, but Engineer Agent did the rewrite). Could you please tell me what is the stop condition for write_code_review
- The total running cost seems to be reset at step1, step2, step3 and step 4. I marked them in Bold.
Both issues
Bug solved method
The prompt I used was: metagpt "We are writing snake in Python. MVC components split in separate files. Keyboard control." The model I used was: gpt-3.5-turbo-16k-0613
The log.txt file: logs.txt
The cost_manager reported 22 GPT calls here:
- 2024-02-15 20:41:23.921 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.005 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.005, prompt_tokens: 958, completion_tokens: 577
- 2024-02-15 20:41:33.327 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.005 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.005, prompt_tokens: 1202, completion_tokens: 416
- 2024-02-15 20:41:40.623 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.003 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.003, prompt_tokens: 901, completion_tokens: 183
- 2024-02-15 20:41:44.489 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.004 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.004, prompt_tokens: 910, completion_tokens: 232
- 2024-02-15 20:41:46.800 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.008 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.005, prompt_tokens: 1359, completion_tokens: 149
- 2024-02-15 20:41:49.157 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.012 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.004, prompt_tokens: 1036, completion_tokens: 139
- 2024-02-15 20:41:52.794 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.017 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.005, prompt_tokens: 1359, completion_tokens: 229
- 2024-02-15 20:41:55.656 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.021 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.004, prompt_tokens: 1116, completion_tokens: 156
- 2024-02-15 20:42:03.266 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.026 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.005, prompt_tokens: 910, completion_tokens: 495
- 2024-02-15 20:42:09.761 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.032 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.007, prompt_tokens: 1575, completion_tokens: 473
- 2024-02-15 20:42:14.749 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.039 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.006, prompt_tokens: 1576, completion_tokens: 383
-
- 2024-02-15 20:42:18.626 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.044 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.006, prompt_tokens: 1575, completion_tokens: 241
- 2024-02-15 20:42:22.186 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.048 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.004, prompt_tokens: 910, completion_tokens: 208
- 2024-02-15 20:42:24.305 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.052 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.005, prompt_tokens: 1343, completion_tokens: 134
- 2024-02-15 20:42:27.682 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.056 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.004, prompt_tokens: 1005, completion_tokens: 218
- 2024-02-15 20:42:29.616 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.061 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.004, prompt_tokens: 1343, completion_tokens: 102
- 2024-02-15 20:42:32.778 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.064 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.004, prompt_tokens: 973, completion_tokens: 200
- 2024-02-15 20:42:35.939 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.068 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.004, prompt_tokens: 910, completion_tokens: 198
- 2024-02-15 20:42:41.923 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.073 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.005, prompt_tokens: 1339, completion_tokens: 366
- 2024-02-15 20:42:48.209 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.078 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.005, prompt_tokens: 1233, completion_tokens: 320
- 2024-02-15 20:42:52.043 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.083 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.005, prompt_tokens: 1379, completion_tokens: 243
- 2024-02-15 20:42:54.487 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.088 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.004, prompt_tokens: 1150, completion_tokens: 158 `
The actions of these calls are:
- WritePRD
- WriteDesign
- Generating Task lists
- write_code: Writing model.py
- write_code_review: Code review and rewrite model.py (not passed 1/2)
- write_code_review: rewrite model.py (1/2)
- write_code_review: Code review and rewrite model.py (passed 2/2) - (passed but why rewrite?)
- write_code_review: rewrite model.py (2/2)
- write_code: Writing view.py
- write_code_review: Code review and rewrite view.py (not passed 1/2)
- write_code_review: rewrite view.py (1/2)
- write_code_review: Code review and rewrite view.py (passed 2/2)
- write_code: Writing controller.py
- write_code_review: Code review and rewrite controller.py (passed 1/2) - (passed but why rewrite?)
- write_code_review: rewrite controller.py
- write_code_review: Code review and rewrite controller.py (passed 2/2) - (passed but why rewrite?)
- write_code_review: rewrite controller.py
- write_code: Writing main.py
- write_code_review: Code review and rewrite main.py (not passed 1/2)
- write_code_review: rewrite main.py (1/2)
- write_code_review: Code review and rewrite main.py (passed 2/2) - (passed but why rewrite?)
- write_code_review: rewrite main.py (2/2)
The issues I encountered are:
- The write_code_review has 2 iterations. After the QA Engineer Agent reported LGTM, and QAE approved the code (saying nothing need to be fixed), Engineer Agent continued to rewrite the code. Is LGTM a stop condition or there's other rules here?
- In MegaGPT default setup, the 'total cost' is not the total cost for all OpenAI API Usage cost. It seemed to be reset at the first four calls. According to the log analysis, the 'total cost' starts to accumulate after the Engineer Agent start writing the code. Is MetaGPT designed to output total cost of each Phase (I assume there's 4 Phases)? Or it is a potential bug? Would you mind helping me clarify this?
Thank you for your help! Appreciated!
Environment information
- LLM type and model name:
- System version: Ubuntu 22.04 Jammy
- Python version: conda - Python 3.9
- Model version: gpt-3.5-turbo-16k-0613
- packages version: MetaGPT v0.7 (pip install -r requirements.txt)
- installation method: pip install
Screenshots or logs
Not sure which version of 0.7 you're using, but the logs indeed indicate so.
1. Write Tasks
2024-02-15 20:41:37.287 | INFO | metagpt.roles.role:_act:399 - Eve(Project Manager): to do WriteTasks(WriteTasks)
[CONTENT]
{
"Required Python packages": [
"pygame==2.0.1"
],
"Required Other language third-party packages": [
"No third-party dependencies required"
],
"Logic Analysis": [
[
"main.py",
"Contains the main function to start the game"
],
[
"model.py",
"Contains the Model class to manage game data"
],
[
"view.py",
"Contains the View class to render the game"
],
[
"controller.py",
"Contains the Controller class to handle user input"
]
],
"Task list": [
"model.py",
"view.py",
"controller.py",
"main.py"
],
"Full API spec": "",
"Shared Knowledge": "",
"Anything UNCLEAR": ""
}
[/CONTENT]
2024-02-15 20:41:40.623 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.003 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.003, prompt_tokens: 901, completion_tokens: 183
2024-02-15 20:41:40.625 | INFO | metagpt.utils.file_repository:save:60 - save to: /home/coppelia/Program/new/MetaGPT-main/workspace/snake_game/docs/task/20240215204123.json
2024-02-15 20:41:40.626 | INFO | metagpt.utils.file_repository:save:65 - update dependency: /home/coppelia/Program/new/MetaGPT-main/workspace/snake_game/docs/task/20240215204123.json:{'docs/system_design/20240215204123.json'}
2. Save requirements.txt
2024-02-15 20:41:40.626 | INFO | metagpt.utils.file_repository:save:60 - save to: /home/coppelia/Program/new/MetaGPT-main/workspace/snake_game/requirements.txt
3. Write model.py
3.1. Write Code 1
2024-02-15 20:41:40.657 | INFO | metagpt.actions.write_code:run:147 - Writing model.py..
\`\`\`python
## model.py
class Model:
def __init__(self):
self.snake = []
self.food = ()
self.score = 0
def get_snake(self):
return self.snake
def get_food(self):
return self.food
def get_score(self):
return self.score
def update_snake(self, new_snake):
self.snake = new_snake
def update_food(self, new_food):
self.food = new_food
def update_score(self, new_score):
self.score = new_score
\`\`\`
Explanation:
- The `Model` class represents the game data and provides methods to access and update the snake, food, and score.
- The `__init__` method initializes the snake, food, and score with default values.
- The `get_snake`, `get_food`, and `get_score` methods return the current values of the snake, food, and score respectively.
- The `update_snake`, `update_food`, and `update_score` methods update the snake, food, and score with new values respectively.
2024-02-15 20:41:44.489 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.004 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.004, prompt_tokens: 910, completion_tokens: 232
3.2. Code Review 1
2024-02-15 20:41:44.489 | INFO | metagpt.actions.write_code_review:run:183 - Code review and rewrite model.py: 1/2 | len(iterative_code)=483, len(self.i_context.code_doc.content)=483
## Code Review: model.py
1. Yes, the code is implemented as per the requirements.
2. Yes, the code logic is correct.
3. Yes, the code follows the "Data structures and interfaces" as described in the class diagram.
4. Yes, all functions are implemented.
5. No, the necessary pre-dependencies are not imported. The code should import the `pygame` package.
6. No, there are no methods from other files being reused in this code.
## Actions:
1. Import the necessary pre-dependencies by adding the following line at the top of the file:
\`\`\`python
import pygame
\`\`\`
2. No further actions are needed.
## Code Review Result:
LBTM
2024-02-15 20:41:46.800 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.008 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.005, prompt_tokens: 1359, completion_tokens: 149
3.3. Write Code 2
## Rewrite Code: model.py
\`\`\`python
## model.py
class Model:
def __init__(self):
self.snake = []
self.food = ()
self.score = 0
def get_snake(self):
return self.snake
def get_food(self):
return self.food
def get_score(self):
return self.score
def update_snake(self, new_snake):
self.snake = new_snake
def update_food(self, new_food):
self.food = new_food
def update_score(self, new_score):
self.score = new_score
\`\`\`
## Code Review Result:
LBTM
2024-02-15 20:41:49.157 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.012 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.004, prompt_tokens: 1036, completion_tokens: 139
3.4. Code Review 2
2024-02-15 20:41:49.157 | INFO | metagpt.actions.write_code_review:run:183 - Code review and rewrite model.py: 2/2 | len(iterative_code)=483, len(self.i_context.code_doc.content)=483
## Code Review: model.py
1. Is the code implemented as per the requirements? If not, how to achieve it? Analyse it step by step.
- Yes, the code implements the Model class as required.
2. Is the code logic completely correct? If there are errors, please indicate how to correct them.
- The code logic appears to be correct.
3. Does the existing code follow the "Data structures and interfaces"?
- Yes, the existing code follows the data structures and interfaces defined in the class diagram.
4. Are all functions implemented? If there is no implementation, please indicate how to achieve it step by step.
- Yes, all the required functions are implemented in the Model class.
5. Have all necessary pre-dependencies been imported? If not, indicate which ones need to be imported.
- No pre-dependencies are required in the Model class.
6. Are methods from other files being reused correctly?
- There are no methods from other files being reused in the Model class.
## Actions: No actions required for the Model class.
## Code Review Result: LGTM
2024-02-15 20:41:52.794 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.017 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.005, prompt_tokens: 1359, completion_tokens: 229
3.5. Write Code 3
## Rewrite Code: model.py
\`\`\`python
## model.py
class Model:
def __init__(self):
self.snake = []
self.food = ()
self.score = 0
def get_snake(self):
return self.snake
def get_food(self):
return self.food
def get_score(self):
return self.score
def update_snake(self, new_snake):
self.snake = new_snake
def update_food(self, new_food):
self.food = new_food
def update_score(self, new_score):
self.score = new_score
\`\`\`
The code in the `model.py` file is already well-implemented and follows the requirements. No further changes are needed.
2024-02-15 20:41:55.656 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.021 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.004, prompt_tokens: 1116, completion_tokens: 156
2024-02-15 20:41:55.657 | INFO | metagpt.utils.file_repository:save:60 - save to: /home/coppelia/Program/new/MetaGPT-main/workspace/snake_game/snake_game/model.py
2024-02-15 20:41:55.658 | INFO | metagpt.utils.file_repository:save:65 - update dependency: /home/coppelia/Program/new/MetaGPT-main/workspace/snake_game/snake_game/model.py:{'docs/task/20240215204123.json', 'docs/system_design/20240215204123.json'}
However, I tested with version 0.7.3 and didn't reproduce this issue.
1. Write Tasks
2024-03-04 15:03:34.348 | INFO | metagpt.roles.role:_act:399 - Eve(Project Manager): to do WriteTasks(WriteTasks)
2024-03-04 15:03:34.404 | DEBUG | metagpt.roles.role:run:555 - Alex(Engineer): no news. waiting.
2024-03-04 15:03:34.405 | DEBUG | metagpt.roles.role:run:555 - Edward(QaEngineer): no news. waiting.
2024-03-04 15:03:34.409 | DEBUG | metagpt.provider.base_llm:aask:88 - [{'role': 'system', 'content': 'You are a Project Manager, named Eve, your goal is break down tasks according to PRD/technical design, generate a task list, and analyze task dependencies to start with the prerequisite modules. the constraint is use same language as user requirement. '}, {'role': 'user', 'content': '\n## context\n{"Implementation approach":"We will use the Pygame library to create the snake game in Python. Pygame provides a simple and easy-to-use framework for game development, including handling keyboard inputs and rendering graphics.","File list":["main.py","game.py","snake.py","ui.py"],"Data structures and interfaces":"\\nclassDiagram\\n class Game {\\n -int score\\n -bool game_over\\n -Snake snake\\n +__init__()\\n +update()\\n +draw()\\n }\\n class Snake {\\n -list body\\n -str direction\\n +__init__()\\n +change_direction()\\n +move()\\n +eat()\\n }\\n class UI {\\n -Game game\\n +__init__()\\n +update_score()\\n +update_game_status()\\n +draw()\\n }\\n Game --> Snake\\n Game --> UI\\n","Program call flow":"\\nsequenceDiagram\\n participant M as Main\\n participant G as Game\\n participant S as Snake\\n participant U as UI\\n M->>G: __init__()\\n loop Game Loop\\n G->>S: update()\\n S->>S: move()\\n G->>U: update_score()\\n G->>U: update_game_status()\\n G->>G: draw()\\n end\\n","Anything UNCLEAR":""}\n\n-----\n\n## format example\n[CONTENT]\n{\n "Required Python packages": [\n "flask==1.1.2",\n "bcrypt==3.2.0"\n ],\n "Required Other language third-party packages": [\n "No third-party dependencies required"\n ],\n "Logic Analysis": [\n [\n "game.py",\n "Contains Game class and ... functions"\n ],\n [\n "main.py",\n "Contains main function, from game import Game"\n ]\n ],\n "Task list": [\n "game.py",\n "main.py"\n ],\n "Full API spec": "openapi: 3.0.0 ...",\n "Shared Knowledge": "`game.py` contains functions shared across the project.",\n "Anything UNCLEAR": "Clarification needed on how to start and initialize third-party libraries."\n}\n[/CONTENT]\n\n## nodes: "<node>: <type> # <instruction>"\n- Required Python packages: typing.List[str] # Provide required Python packages in requirements.txt format.\n- Required Other language third-party packages: typing.List[str] # List down the required packages for languages other than Python.\n- Logic Analysis: typing.List[typing.List[str]] # Provide a list of files with the classes/methods/functions to be implemented, including dependency analysis and imports.\n- Task list: typing.List[str] # Break down the tasks into a list of filenames, prioritized by dependency order.\n- Full API spec: <class \'str\'> # Describe all APIs using OpenAPI 3.0 spec that may be used by both frontend and backend. If front-end and back-end communication is not required, leave it blank.\n- Shared Knowledge: <class \'str\'> # Detail any shared knowledge, like common utility functions or configuration variables.\n- Anything UNCLEAR: <class \'str\'> # Mention any unclear aspects in the project management context and try to clarify them.\n\n\n## constraint\nLanguage: Please use the same language as Human INPUT.\nFormat: output wrapped inside [CONTENT][/CONTENT] like format example, nothing else.\n\n## action\nFollow instructions of nodes, generate output and make sure it follows the format example.\n'}]
2024-03-04 15:03:37.201 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.001 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.001, prompt_tokens: 817, completion_tokens: 204
2024-03-04 15:03:37.201 | DEBUG | metagpt.actions.action_node:_aask_v1:423 - llm raw output:
[CONTENT]
{
"Required Python packages": [
"pygame==2.0.1"
],
"Required Other language third-party packages": [
"No third-party dependencies required"
],
"Logic Analysis": [
[
"game.py",
"Contains Game class and ... functions"
],
[
"main.py",
"Contains main function, from game import Game"
],
[
"snake.py",
"Contains Snake class and ... functions"
],
[
"ui.py",
"Contains UI class and ... functions"
]
],
"Task list": [
"game.py",
"snake.py",
"ui.py",
"main.py"
],
"Full API spec": "",
"Shared Knowledge": "`game.py` contains functions shared across the project.",
"Anything UNCLEAR": "Clarification needed on how to handle user inputs and render graphics using Pygame library."
}
[/CONTENT]
2024-03-04 15:03:37.212 | DEBUG | metagpt.actions.action_node:_aask_v1:433 - parsed_data:
{'Required Python packages': ['pygame==2.0.1'], 'Required Other language third-party packages': ['No third-party dependencies required'], 'Logic Analysis': [['game.py', 'Contains Game class and ... functions'], ['main.py', 'Contains main function, from game import Game'], ['snake.py', 'Contains Snake class and ... functions'], ['ui.py', 'Contains UI class and ... functions']], 'Task list': ['game.py', 'snake.py', 'ui.py', 'main.py'], 'Full API spec': '', 'Shared Knowledge': '`game.py` contains functions shared across the project.', 'Anything UNCLEAR': 'Clarification needed on how to handle user inputs and render graphics using Pygame library.'}
2024-03-04 15:03:37.214 | INFO | metagpt.utils.file_repository:save:60 - save to: /Users/iorishinier/github/bak/MetaGPT/workspace/snake_python/docs/task/20240304150313.json
2024-03-04 15:03:37.217 | INFO | metagpt.utils.file_repository:save:65 - update dependency: /Users/iorishinier/github/bak/MetaGPT/workspace/snake_python/docs/task/20240304150313.json:{'docs/system_design/20240304150313.json'}
2. Write requirements.txt
2024-03-04 15:03:37.219 | INFO | metagpt.utils.file_repository:save:60 - save to: /Users/iorishinier/github/bak/MetaGPT/workspace/snake_python/requirements.txt
3. Write game.py(LBTM)
3.1. Write Code 1
2024-03-04 15:03:37.221 | DEBUG | metagpt.roles.role:_set_state:334 - actions=[WriteTasks], state=-1
2024-03-04 15:03:37.224 | DEBUG | metagpt.environment.base_env:publish_message:144 - publish_message: {"id":"afb7f238c1ef4cab817c6ff0a6cf5bb9","content":"{\"docs\":{\"20240304150313.json\":{\"root_path\":\"docs/task\",\"filename\":\"20240304150313.json\",\"content\":\"{\\\"Required Python packages\\\":[\\\"pygame==2.0.1\\\"],\\\"Required Other language third-party packages\\\":[\\\"No third-party dependencies required\\\"],\\\"Logic Analysis\\\":[[\\\"game.py\\\",\\\"Contains Game class and ... functions\\\"],[\\\"main.py\\\",\\\"Contains main function, from game import Game\\\"],[\\\"snake.py\\\",\\\"Contains Snake class and ... functions\\\"],[\\\"ui.py\\\",\\\"Contains UI class and ... functions\\\"]],\\\"Task list\\\":[\\\"game.py\\\",\\\"snake.py\\\",\\\"ui.py\\\",\\\"main.py\\\"],\\\"Full API spec\\\":\\\"\\\",\\\"Shared Knowledge\\\":\\\"`game.py` contains functions shared across the project.\\\",\\\"Anything UNCLEAR\\\":\\\"Clarification needed on how to handle user inputs and render graphics using Pygame library.\\\"}\"}}}","instruct_content":{"class":"Documents","module":"metagpt.schema","value":{"docs":{"20240304150313.json":{"root_path":"docs/task","filename":"20240304150313.json","content":"{\"Required Python packages\":[\"pygame==2.0.1\"],\"Required Other language third-party packages\":[\"No third-party dependencies required\"],\"Logic Analysis\":[[\"game.py\",\"Contains Game class and ... functions\"],[\"main.py\",\"Contains main function, from game import Game\"],[\"snake.py\",\"Contains Snake class and ... functions\"],[\"ui.py\",\"Contains UI class and ... functions\"]],\"Task list\":[\"game.py\",\"snake.py\",\"ui.py\",\"main.py\"],\"Full API spec\":\"\",\"Shared Knowledge\":\"`game.py` contains functions shared across the project.\",\"Anything UNCLEAR\":\"Clarification needed on how to handle user inputs and render graphics using Pygame library.\"}"}}}},"role":"Eve(Project Manager)","cause_by":"metagpt.actions.project_management.WriteTasks","sent_from":"metagpt.roles.project_manager.ProjectManager","send_to":["<all>"]}
2024-03-04 15:03:37.225 | DEBUG | metagpt.environment.base_env:run:168 - is idle: False
2024-03-04 15:03:37.225 | DEBUG | metagpt.team:run:131 - max n_round=95 left.
2024-03-04 15:03:37.226 | DEBUG | metagpt.roles.role:run:555 - Alice(Product Manager): no news. waiting.
2024-03-04 15:03:37.226 | DEBUG | metagpt.roles.role:run:555 - Bob(Architect): no news. waiting.
2024-03-04 15:03:37.226 | DEBUG | metagpt.roles.role:run:555 - Eve(Project Manager): no news. waiting.
2024-03-04 15:03:37.227 | DEBUG | metagpt.roles.role:_observe:439 - Alex(Engineer) observed: ['Eve(Project Manager): {"docs":{"2024030415...']
2024-03-04 15:03:37.231 | DEBUG | metagpt.roles.engineer:_think:256 - TODO WriteCode:{"id":"afb7f238c1ef4cab817c6ff0a6cf5bb9","content":"{\"docs\":{\"20240304150313.json\":{\"root_path\":\"docs/task\",\"filename\":\"20240304150313.json\",\"content\":\"{\\\"Required Python packages\\\":[\\\"pygame==2.0.1\\\"],\\\"Required Other language third-party packages\\\":[\\\"No third-party dependencies required\\\"],\\\"Logic Analysis\\\":[[\\\"game.py\\\",\\\"Contains Game class and ... functions\\\"],[\\\"main.py\\\",\\\"Contains main function, from game import Game\\\"],[\\\"snake.py\\\",\\\"Contains Snake class and ... functions\\\"],[\\\"ui.py\\\",\\\"Contains UI class and ... functions\\\"]],\\\"Task list\\\":[\\\"game.py\\\",\\\"snake.py\\\",\\\"ui.py\\\",\\\"main.py\\\"],\\\"Full API spec\\\":\\\"\\\",\\\"Shared Knowledge\\\":\\\"`game.py` contains functions shared across the project.\\\",\\\"Anything UNCLEAR\\\":\\\"Clarification needed on how to handle user inputs and render graphics using Pygame library.\\\"}\"}}}","instruct_content":{"class":"Documents","module":"metagpt.schema","value":{"docs":{"20240304150313.json":{"root_path":"docs/task","filename":"20240304150313.json","content":"{\"Required Python packages\":[\"pygame==2.0.1\"],\"Required Other language third-party packages\":[\"No third-party dependencies required\"],\"Logic Analysis\":[[\"game.py\",\"Contains Game class and ... functions\"],[\"main.py\",\"Contains main function, from game import Game\"],[\"snake.py\",\"Contains Snake class and ... functions\"],[\"ui.py\",\"Contains UI class and ... functions\"]],\"Task list\":[\"game.py\",\"snake.py\",\"ui.py\",\"main.py\"],\"Full API spec\":\"\",\"Shared Knowledge\":\"`game.py` contains functions shared across the project.\",\"Anything UNCLEAR\":\"Clarification needed on how to handle user inputs and render graphics using Pygame library.\"}"}}}},"role":"Eve(Project Manager)","cause_by":"metagpt.actions.project_management.WriteTasks","sent_from":"metagpt.roles.project_manager.ProjectManager","send_to":["<all>"]}
2024-03-04 15:03:37.297 | DEBUG | metagpt.roles.role:run:555 - Edward(QaEngineer): no news. waiting.
2024-03-04 15:03:37.364 | DEBUG | metagpt.roles.role:_react:470 - Alex(Engineer): self.rc.state=-1, will do WriteCode
2024-03-04 15:03:41.208 | INFO | metagpt.actions.write_code:run:147 - Writing game.py..
2024-03-04 15:03:41.209 | DEBUG | metagpt.provider.base_llm:aask:88 - [{'role': 'system', 'content': 'You are a Engineer, named Alex, your goal is write elegant, readable, extensible, efficient code. the constraint is the code should conform to standards like google-style and be modular and maintainable. Use same language as user requirement. '}, {'role': 'user', 'content': '\nNOTICE\nRole: You are a professional engineer; the main goal is to write google-style, elegant, modular, easy to read and maintain code\nLanguage: Please use the same language as the user requirement, but the title and code should be still in English. For example, if the user speaks Chinese, the specific text of your answer should also be in Chinese.\nATTENTION: Use \'##\' to SPLIT SECTIONS, not \'#\'. Output format carefully referenced "Format example".\n\n# Context\n## Design\n{"Implementation approach":"We will use the Pygame library to create the snake game in Python. Pygame provides a simple and easy-to-use framework for game development, including handling keyboard inputs and rendering graphics.","File list":["main.py","game.py","snake.py","ui.py"],"Data structures and interfaces":"\\nclassDiagram\\n class Game {\\n -int score\\n -bool game_over\\n -Snake snake\\n +__init__()\\n +update()\\n +draw()\\n }\\n class Snake {\\n -list body\\n -str direction\\n +__init__()\\n +change_direction()\\n +move()\\n +eat()\\n }\\n class UI {\\n -Game game\\n +__init__()\\n +update_score()\\n +update_game_status()\\n +draw()\\n }\\n Game --> Snake\\n Game --> UI\\n","Program call flow":"\\nsequenceDiagram\\n participant M as Main\\n participant G as Game\\n participant S as Snake\\n participant U as UI\\n M->>G: __init__()\\n loop Game Loop\\n G->>S: update()\\n S->>S: move()\\n G->>U: update_score()\\n G->>U: update_game_status()\\n G->>G: draw()\\n end\\n","Anything UNCLEAR":""}\n\n## Task\n{"Required Python packages":["pygame==2.0.1"],"Required Other language third-party packages":["No third-party dependencies required"],"Logic Analysis":[["game.py","Contains Game class and ... functions"],["main.py","Contains main function, from game import Game"],["snake.py","Contains Snake class and ... functions"],["ui.py","Contains UI class and ... functions"]],"Task list":["game.py","snake.py","ui.py","main.py"],"Full API spec":"","Shared Knowledge":"`game.py` contains functions shared across the project.","Anything UNCLEAR":"Clarification needed on how to handle user inputs and render graphics using Pygame library."}\n\n## Legacy Code\n```Code\n\n```\n\n## Debug logs\n```text\n\n\n\n```\n\n## Bug Feedback logs\n```text\n\n```\n\n# Format example\n## Code: game.py\n```python\n## game.py\n...\n```\n\n# Instruction: Based on the context, follow "Format example", write code.\n\n## Code: game.py. Write code with triple quoto, based on the following attentions and context.\n1. Only One file: do your best to implement THIS ONLY ONE FILE.\n2. COMPLETE CODE: Your code will be part of the entire project, so please implement complete, reliable, reusable code snippets.\n3. Set default value: If there is any setting, ALWAYS SET A DEFAULT VALUE, ALWAYS USE STRONG TYPE AND EXPLICIT VARIABLE. AVOID circular import.\n4. Follow design: YOU MUST FOLLOW "Data structures and interfaces". DONT CHANGE ANY DESIGN. Do not use public member functions that do not exist in your design.\n5. CAREFULLY CHECK THAT YOU DONT MISS ANY NECESSARY CLASS/FUNCTION IN THIS FILE.\n6. Before using a external variable/module, make sure you import it first.\n7. Write out EVERY CODE DETAIL, DON\'T LEAVE TODO.\n\n'}]
2024-03-04 15:03:42.744 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.001 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.001, prompt_tokens: 848, completion_tokens: 69
2024-03-04 15:03:57.655 | INFO | metagpt.actions.write_code_review:run:183 - Code review and rewrite game.py: 1/2 | len(iterative_code)=268, len(self.i_context.code_doc.content)=268
3.2. Code Review 1
2024-03-04 15:04:01.554 | DEBUG | metagpt.provider.base_llm:aask:88 - [{'role': 'system', 'content': 'You are a Engineer, named Alex, your goal is write elegant, readable, extensible, efficient code. the constraint is the code should conform to standards like google-style and be modular and maintainable. Use same language as user requirement. '}, {'role': 'user', 'content': '\n# System\nRole: You are a professional software engineer, and your main task is to review and revise the code. You need to ensure that the code conforms to the google-style standards, is elegantly designed and modularized, easy to read and maintain.\nLanguage: Please use the same language as the user requirement, but the title and code should be still in English. For example, if the user speaks Chinese, the specific text of your answer should also be in Chinese.\nATTENTION: Use \'##\' to SPLIT SECTIONS, not \'#\'. Output format carefully referenced "Format example".\n\n# Context\n## System Design\n{"Implementation approach":"We will use the Pygame library to create the snake game in Python. Pygame provides a simple and easy-to-use framework for game development, including handling keyboard inputs and rendering graphics.","File list":["main.py","game.py","snake.py","ui.py"],"Data structures and interfaces":"\\nclassDiagram\\n class Game {\\n -int score\\n -bool game_over\\n -Snake snake\\n +__init__()\\n +update()\\n +draw()\\n }\\n class Snake {\\n -list body\\n -str direction\\n +__init__()\\n +change_direction()\\n +move()\\n +eat()\\n }\\n class UI {\\n -Game game\\n +__init__()\\n +update_score()\\n +update_game_status()\\n +draw()\\n }\\n Game --> Snake\\n Game --> UI\\n","Program call flow":"\\nsequenceDiagram\\n participant M as Main\\n participant G as Game\\n participant S as Snake\\n participant U as UI\\n M->>G: __init__()\\n loop Game Loop\\n G->>S: update()\\n S->>S: move()\\n G->>U: update_score()\\n G->>U: update_game_status()\\n G->>G: draw()\\n end\\n","Anything UNCLEAR":""}\n\n## Task\n{"Required Python packages":["pygame==2.0.1"],"Required Other language third-party packages":["No third-party dependencies required"],"Logic Analysis":[["game.py","Contains Game class and ... functions"],["main.py","Contains main function, from game import Game"],["snake.py","Contains Snake class and ... functions"],["ui.py","Contains UI class and ... functions"]],"Task list":["game.py","snake.py","ui.py","main.py"],"Full API spec":"","Shared Knowledge":"`game.py` contains functions shared across the project.","Anything UNCLEAR":"Clarification needed on how to handle user inputs and render graphics using Pygame library."}\n\n## Code Files\n\n\n\n## Code to be Reviewed: game.py\n```Code\n## game.py\n\nclass Game:\n def __init__(self):\n self.score = 0\n self.game_over = False\n self.snake = Snake()\n\n def update(self):\n # Update game logic here\n pass\n\n def draw(self):\n # Draw game graphics here\n pass\n\n```\n\n\n\n# Format example 1\n## Code Review: game.py\n1. No, we should fix the logic of class A due to ...\n2. ...\n3. ...\n4. No, function B is not implemented, ...\n5. ...\n6. ...\n\n## Actions\n1. Fix the `handle_events` method to update the game state only if a move is successful.\n ```python\n def handle_events(self):\n for event in pygame.event.get():\n if event.type == pygame.QUIT:\n return False\n if event.type == pygame.KEYDOWN:\n moved = False\n if event.key == pygame.K_UP:\n moved = self.game.move(\'UP\')\n elif event.key == pygame.K_DOWN:\n moved = self.game.move(\'DOWN\')\n elif event.key == pygame.K_LEFT:\n moved = self.game.move(\'LEFT\')\n elif event.key == pygame.K_RIGHT:\n moved = self.game.move(\'RIGHT\')\n if moved:\n # Update the game state only if a move was successful\n self.render()\n return True\n ```\n2. Implement function B\n\n## Code Review Result\nLBTM\n\n# Format example 2\n## Code Review: game.py\n1. Yes.\n2. Yes.\n3. Yes.\n4. Yes.\n5. Yes.\n6. Yes.\n\n## Actions\npass\n\n## Code Review Result\nLGTM\n\n\n\n# Instruction: Based on the actual code situation, follow one of the "Format example". Return only 1 file under review.\n\n## Code Review: Ordered List. Based on the "Code to be Reviewed", provide key, clear, concise, and specific answer. If any answer is no, explain how to fix it step by step.\n1. Is the code implemented as per the requirements? If not, how to achieve it? Analyse it step by step.\n2. Is the code logic completely correct? If there are errors, please indicate how to correct them.\n3. Does the existing code follow the "Data structures and interfaces"?\n4. Are all functions implemented? If there is no implementation, please indicate how to achieve it step by step.\n5. Have all necessary pre-dependencies been imported? If not, indicate which ones need to be imported\n6. Are methods from other files being reused correctly?\n\n## Actions: Ordered List. Things that should be done after CR, such as implementing class A and function B\n\n## Code Review Result: str. If the code doesn\'t have bugs, we don\'t need to rewrite it, so answer LGTM and stop. ONLY ANSWER LGTM/LBTM.\nLGTM/LBTM\n\n'}]
2024-03-04 15:04:05.558 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.003 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.002, prompt_tokens: 1243, completion_tokens: 308
3.3. Write Code 2
2024-03-04 15:04:14.525 | DEBUG | metagpt.provider.base_llm:aask:88 - [{'role': 'system', 'content': 'You are a Engineer, named Alex, your goal is write elegant, readable, extensible, efficient code. the constraint is the code should conform to standards like google-style and be modular and maintainable. Use same language as user requirement. '}, {'role': 'user', 'content': '\n# System\nRole: You are a professional software engineer, and your main task is to review and revise the code. You need to ensure that the code conforms to the google-style standards, is elegantly designed and modularized, easy to read and maintain.\nLanguage: Please use the same language as the user requirement, but the title and code should be still in English. For example, if the user speaks Chinese, the specific text of your answer should also be in Chinese.\nATTENTION: Use \'##\' to SPLIT SECTIONS, not \'#\'. Output format carefully referenced "Format example".\n\n# Context\n## System Design\n{"Implementation approach":"We will use the Pygame library to create the snake game in Python. Pygame provides a simple and easy-to-use framework for game development, including handling keyboard inputs and rendering graphics.","File list":["main.py","game.py","snake.py","ui.py"],"Data structures and interfaces":"\\nclassDiagram\\n class Game {\\n -int score\\n -bool game_over\\n -Snake snake\\n +__init__()\\n +update()\\n +draw()\\n }\\n class Snake {\\n -list body\\n -str direction\\n +__init__()\\n +change_direction()\\n +move()\\n +eat()\\n }\\n class UI {\\n -Game game\\n +__init__()\\n +update_score()\\n +update_game_status()\\n +draw()\\n }\\n Game --> Snake\\n Game --> UI\\n","Program call flow":"\\nsequenceDiagram\\n participant M as Main\\n participant G as Game\\n participant S as Snake\\n participant U as UI\\n M->>G: __init__()\\n loop Game Loop\\n G->>S: update()\\n S->>S: move()\\n G->>U: update_score()\\n G->>U: update_game_status()\\n G->>G: draw()\\n end\\n","Anything UNCLEAR":""}\n\n## Task\n{"Required Python packages":["pygame==2.0.1"],"Required Other language third-party packages":["No third-party dependencies required"],"Logic Analysis":[["game.py","Contains Game class and ... functions"],["main.py","Contains main function, from game import Game"],["snake.py","Contains Snake class and ... functions"],["ui.py","Contains UI class and ... functions"]],"Task list":["game.py","snake.py","ui.py","main.py"],"Full API spec":"","Shared Knowledge":"`game.py` contains functions shared across the project.","Anything UNCLEAR":"Clarification needed on how to handle user inputs and render graphics using Pygame library."}\n\n## Code Files\n\n\n\n## Code to be Reviewed: game.py\n```Code\n## game.py\n\nclass Game:\n def __init__(self):\n self.score = 0\n self.game_over = False\n self.snake = Snake()\n\n def update(self):\n # Update game logic here\n pass\n\n def draw(self):\n # Draw game graphics here\n pass\n\n```\n\n## Code Review: game.py\n1. No, the code is not implemented as per the requirements. The Game class should handle user inputs and render graphics using the Pygame library. To achieve this, we need to implement methods for handling user inputs and rendering graphics within the Game class.\n2. The code logic is not completely correct as it lacks the implementation for handling user inputs and rendering graphics using the Pygame library.\n3. Yes, the existing code follows the "Data structures and interfaces" defined in the class diagram.\n4. No, the update and draw methods are not implemented. To achieve this, we need to implement the update method to update the game logic and the draw method to draw game graphics using the Pygame library.\n5. No, the necessary pre-dependencies for Pygame library have not been imported. We need to import the Pygame library to handle user inputs and render graphics.\n6. No, methods from other files are not being reused correctly. We need to import the Snake class from snake.py to the Game class in game.py.\n\n## Actions\n1. Implement methods for handling user inputs and rendering graphics within the Game class to conform to the requirements.\n2. Implement the update method to update the game logic and the draw method to draw game graphics using the Pygame library.\n3. Import the Pygame library to handle user inputs and render graphics.\n4. Import the Snake class from snake.py to the Game class in game.py to reuse methods correctly.\n\n## Code Review Result\nLBTM\n\n# Instruction: rewrite code based on the Code Review and Actions\n## Rewrite Code: CodeBlock. If it still has some bugs, rewrite game.py with triple quotes. Do your utmost to optimize THIS SINGLE FILE. Return all completed codes and prohibit the return of unfinished codes.\n```Code\n## game.py\n...\n```\n'}]
2024-03-04 15:04:18.010 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.004 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.002, prompt_tokens: 1079, completion_tokens: 216
3.4. Code Review 2
2024-03-04 15:04:43.642 | INFO | metagpt.actions.write_code_review:run:183 - Code review and rewrite game.py: 2/2 | len(iterative_code)=957, len(self.i_context.code_doc.content)=268
2024-03-04 15:04:47.338 | DEBUG | metagpt.provider.base_llm:aask:88 - [{'role': 'system', 'content': 'You are a Engineer, named Alex, your goal is write elegant, readable, extensible, efficient code. the constraint is the code should conform to standards like google-style and be modular and maintainable. Use same language as user requirement. '}, {'role': 'user', 'content': '\n# System\nRole: You are a professional software engineer, and your main task is to review and revise the code. You need to ensure that the code conforms to the google-style standards, is elegantly designed and modularized, easy to read and maintain.\nLanguage: Please use the same language as the user requirement, but the title and code should be still in English. For example, if the user speaks Chinese, the specific text of your answer should also be in Chinese.\nATTENTION: Use \'##\' to SPLIT SECTIONS, not \'#\'. Output format carefully referenced "Format example".\n\n# Context\n## System Design\n{"Implementation approach":"We will use the Pygame library to create the snake game in Python. Pygame provides a simple and easy-to-use framework for game development, including handling keyboard inputs and rendering graphics.","File list":["main.py","game.py","snake.py","ui.py"],"Data structures and interfaces":"\\nclassDiagram\\n class Game {\\n -int score\\n -bool game_over\\n -Snake snake\\n +__init__()\\n +update()\\n +draw()\\n }\\n class Snake {\\n -list body\\n -str direction\\n +__init__()\\n +change_direction()\\n +move()\\n +eat()\\n }\\n class UI {\\n -Game game\\n +__init__()\\n +update_score()\\n +update_game_status()\\n +draw()\\n }\\n Game --> Snake\\n Game --> UI\\n","Program call flow":"\\nsequenceDiagram\\n participant M as Main\\n participant G as Game\\n participant S as Snake\\n participant U as UI\\n M->>G: __init__()\\n loop Game Loop\\n G->>S: update()\\n S->>S: move()\\n G->>U: update_score()\\n G->>U: update_game_status()\\n G->>G: draw()\\n end\\n","Anything UNCLEAR":""}\n\n## Task\n{"Required Python packages":["pygame==2.0.1"],"Required Other language third-party packages":["No third-party dependencies required"],"Logic Analysis":[["game.py","Contains Game class and ... functions"],["main.py","Contains main function, from game import Game"],["snake.py","Contains Snake class and ... functions"],["ui.py","Contains UI class and ... functions"]],"Task list":["game.py","snake.py","ui.py","main.py"],"Full API spec":"","Shared Knowledge":"`game.py` contains functions shared across the project.","Anything UNCLEAR":"Clarification needed on how to handle user inputs and render graphics using Pygame library."}\n\n## Code Files\n\n\n\n## Code to be Reviewed: game.py\n```Code\n## game.py\n\nimport pygame\nfrom snake import Snake\n\nclass Game:\n def __init__(self):\n self.score = 0\n self.game_over = False\n self.snake = Snake()\n pygame.init()\n self.screen = pygame.display.set_mode((800, 600))\n pygame.display.set_caption(\'Snake Game\')\n\n def handle_user_input(self):\n # Handle user input events here\n for event in pygame.event.get():\n if event.type == pygame.QUIT:\n self.game_over = True\n\n def update(self):\n # Update game logic here\n self.snake.move()\n self.check_collision()\n self.check_eat()\n\n def draw(self):\n # Draw game graphics here\n self.screen.fill((0, 0, 0))\n self.snake.draw(self.screen)\n pygame.display.update()\n\n def check_collision(self):\n # Check collision logic here\n pass\n\n def check_eat(self):\n # Check if the snake eats something\n pass\n\n```\n\n\n\n# Format example 1\n## Code Review: game.py\n1. No, we should fix the logic of class A due to ...\n2. ...\n3. ...\n4. No, function B is not implemented, ...\n5. ...\n6. ...\n\n## Actions\n1. Fix the `handle_events` method to update the game state only if a move is successful.\n ```python\n def handle_events(self):\n for event in pygame.event.get():\n if event.type == pygame.QUIT:\n return False\n if event.type == pygame.KEYDOWN:\n moved = False\n if event.key == pygame.K_UP:\n moved = self.game.move(\'UP\')\n elif event.key == pygame.K_DOWN:\n moved = self.game.move(\'DOWN\')\n elif event.key == pygame.K_LEFT:\n moved = self.game.move(\'LEFT\')\n elif event.key == pygame.K_RIGHT:\n moved = self.game.move(\'RIGHT\')\n if moved:\n # Update the game state only if a move was successful\n self.render()\n return True\n ```\n2. Implement function B\n\n## Code Review Result\nLBTM\n\n# Format example 2\n## Code Review: game.py\n1. Yes.\n2. Yes.\n3. Yes.\n4. Yes.\n5. Yes.\n6. Yes.\n\n## Actions\npass\n\n## Code Review Result\nLGTM\n\n\n\n# Instruction: Based on the actual code situation, follow one of the "Format example". Return only 1 file under review.\n\n## Code Review: Ordered List. Based on the "Code to be Reviewed", provide key, clear, concise, and specific answer. If any answer is no, explain how to fix it step by step.\n1. Is the code implemented as per the requirements? If not, how to achieve it? Analyse it step by step.\n2. Is the code logic completely correct? If there are errors, please indicate how to correct them.\n3. Does the existing code follow the "Data structures and interfaces"?\n4. Are all functions implemented? If there is no implementation, please indicate how to achieve it step by step.\n5. Have all necessary pre-dependencies been imported? If not, indicate which ones need to be imported\n6. Are methods from other files being reused correctly?\n\n## Actions: Ordered List. Things that should be done after CR, such as implementing class A and function B\n\n## Code Review Result: str. If the code doesn\'t have bugs, we don\'t need to rewrite it, so answer LGTM and stop. ONLY ANSWER LGTM/LBTM.\nLGTM/LBTM\n\n'}]
2024-03-04 15:04:51.790 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.006 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.002, prompt_tokens: 1389, completion_tokens: 251
3.5. Write Code 3
2024-03-04 15:04:54.769 | DEBUG | metagpt.provider.base_llm:aask:88 - [{'role': 'system', 'content': 'You are a Engineer, named Alex, your goal is write elegant, readable, extensible, efficient code. the constraint is the code should conform to standards like google-style and be modular and maintainable. Use same language as user requirement. '}, {'role': 'user', 'content': '\n# System\nRole: You are a professional software engineer, and your main task is to review and revise the code. You need to ensure that the code conforms to the google-style standards, is elegantly designed and modularized, easy to read and maintain.\nLanguage: Please use the same language as the user requirement, but the title and code should be still in English. For example, if the user speaks Chinese, the specific text of your answer should also be in Chinese.\nATTENTION: Use \'##\' to SPLIT SECTIONS, not \'#\'. Output format carefully referenced "Format example".\n\n# Context\n## System Design\n{"Implementation approach":"We will use the Pygame library to create the snake game in Python. Pygame provides a simple and easy-to-use framework for game development, including handling keyboard inputs and rendering graphics.","File list":["main.py","game.py","snake.py","ui.py"],"Data structures and interfaces":"\\nclassDiagram\\n class Game {\\n -int score\\n -bool game_over\\n -Snake snake\\n +__init__()\\n +update()\\n +draw()\\n }\\n class Snake {\\n -list body\\n -str direction\\n +__init__()\\n +change_direction()\\n +move()\\n +eat()\\n }\\n class UI {\\n -Game game\\n +__init__()\\n +update_score()\\n +update_game_status()\\n +draw()\\n }\\n Game --> Snake\\n Game --> UI\\n","Program call flow":"\\nsequenceDiagram\\n participant M as Main\\n participant G as Game\\n participant S as Snake\\n participant U as UI\\n M->>G: __init__()\\n loop Game Loop\\n G->>S: update()\\n S->>S: move()\\n G->>U: update_score()\\n G->>U: update_game_status()\\n G->>G: draw()\\n end\\n","Anything UNCLEAR":""}\n\n## Task\n{"Required Python packages":["pygame==2.0.1"],"Required Other language third-party packages":["No third-party dependencies required"],"Logic Analysis":[["game.py","Contains Game class and ... functions"],["main.py","Contains main function, from game import Game"],["snake.py","Contains Snake class and ... functions"],["ui.py","Contains UI class and ... functions"]],"Task list":["game.py","snake.py","ui.py","main.py"],"Full API spec":"","Shared Knowledge":"`game.py` contains functions shared across the project.","Anything UNCLEAR":"Clarification needed on how to handle user inputs and render graphics using Pygame library."}\n\n## Code Files\n\n\n\n## Code to be Reviewed: game.py\n```Code\n## game.py\n\nimport pygame\nfrom snake import Snake\n\nclass Game:\n def __init__(self):\n self.score = 0\n self.game_over = False\n self.snake = Snake()\n pygame.init()\n self.screen = pygame.display.set_mode((800, 600))\n pygame.display.set_caption(\'Snake Game\')\n\n def handle_user_input(self):\n # Handle user input events here\n for event in pygame.event.get():\n if event.type == pygame.QUIT:\n self.game_over = True\n\n def update(self):\n # Update game logic here\n self.snake.move()\n self.check_collision()\n self.check_eat()\n\n def draw(self):\n # Draw game graphics here\n self.screen.fill((0, 0, 0))\n self.snake.draw(self.screen)\n pygame.display.update()\n\n def check_collision(self):\n # Check collision logic here\n pass\n\n def check_eat(self):\n # Check if the snake eats something\n pass\n\n```\n\n## Code Review: game.py\n1. Yes, the code is implemented as per the requirements. It initializes the game, handles user input, updates game logic, and draws game graphics.\n2. The code logic is not completely correct. The `handle_user_input` method should handle user input events and update the game state accordingly.\n3. Yes, the existing code follows the "Data structures and interfaces" defined in the class diagram.\n4. The `check_collision` and `check_eat` functions are not implemented. These functions need to be implemented to check for collision and eating logic.\n5. Yes, all necessary pre-dependencies have been imported. The `pygame` package is imported for game development.\n6. No methods from other files are being reused in the current code.\n\n## Actions\n1. Fix the `handle_user_input` method to handle user input events and update the game state accordingly.\n ```python\n def handle_user_input(self):\n for event in pygame.event.get():\n if event.type == pygame.QUIT:\n self.game_over = True\n ```\n2. Implement the `check_collision` and `check_eat` functions to handle collision and eating logic.\n\n## Code Review Result\nLBTM\n\n# Instruction: rewrite code based on the Code Review and Actions\n## Rewrite Code: CodeBlock. If it still has some bugs, rewrite game.py with triple quotes. Do your utmost to optimize THIS SINGLE FILE. Return all completed codes and prohibit the return of unfinished codes.\n```Code\n## game.py\n...\n```\n'}]
2024-03-04 15:04:57.526 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.008 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.002, prompt_tokens: 1168, completion_tokens: 192
2024-03-04 15:05:05.690 | INFO | metagpt.utils.file_repository:save:60 - save to: /Users/iorishinier/github/bak/MetaGPT/workspace/snake_python/snake_python/game.py
2024-03-04 15:05:05.693 | INFO | metagpt.utils.file_repository:save:65 - update dependency: /Users/iorishinier/github/bak/MetaGPT/workspace/snake_python/snake_python/game.py:{'docs/task/20240304150313.json', 'docs/system_design/20240304150313.json'}
4. Write snake.py(LGTM)
4.1. Write Code 1
2024-03-04 15:05:58.798 | INFO | metagpt.actions.write_code:run:147 - Writing snake.py..
2024-03-04 15:05:58.800 | DEBUG | metagpt.provider.base_llm:aask:88 - [{'role': 'system', 'content': 'You are a Engineer, named Alex, your goal is write elegant, readable, extensible, efficient code. the constraint is the code should conform to standards like google-style and be modular and maintainable. Use same language as user requirement. '}, {'role': 'user', 'content': '\nNOTICE\nRole: You are a professional engineer; the main goal is to write google-style, elegant, modular, easy to read and maintain code\nLanguage: Please use the same language as the user requirement, but the title and code should be still in English. For example, if the user speaks Chinese, the specific text of your answer should also be in Chinese.\nATTENTION: Use \'##\' to SPLIT SECTIONS, not \'#\'. Output format carefully referenced "Format example".\n\n# Context\n## Design\n{"Implementation approach":"We will use the Pygame library to create the snake game in Python. Pygame provides a simple and easy-to-use framework for game development, including handling keyboard inputs and rendering graphics.","File list":["main.py","game.py","snake.py","ui.py"],"Data structures and interfaces":"\\nclassDiagram\\n class Game {\\n -int score\\n -bool game_over\\n -Snake snake\\n +__init__()\\n +update()\\n +draw()\\n }\\n class Snake {\\n -list body\\n -str direction\\n +__init__()\\n +change_direction()\\n +move()\\n +eat()\\n }\\n class UI {\\n -Game game\\n +__init__()\\n +update_score()\\n +update_game_status()\\n +draw()\\n }\\n Game --> Snake\\n Game --> UI\\n","Program call flow":"\\nsequenceDiagram\\n participant M as Main\\n participant G as Game\\n participant S as Snake\\n participant U as UI\\n M->>G: __init__()\\n loop Game Loop\\n G->>S: update()\\n S->>S: move()\\n G->>U: update_score()\\n G->>U: update_game_status()\\n G->>G: draw()\\n end\\n","Anything UNCLEAR":""}\n\n## Task\n{"Required Python packages":["pygame==2.0.1"],"Required Other language third-party packages":["No third-party dependencies required"],"Logic Analysis":[["game.py","Contains Game class and ... functions"],["main.py","Contains main function, from game import Game"],["snake.py","Contains Snake class and ... functions"],["ui.py","Contains UI class and ... functions"]],"Task list":["game.py","snake.py","ui.py","main.py"],"Full API spec":"","Shared Knowledge":"`game.py` contains functions shared across the project.","Anything UNCLEAR":"Clarification needed on how to handle user inputs and render graphics using Pygame library."}\n\n## Legacy Code\n```Code\n\n```\n\n## Debug logs\n```text\n\n\n\n```\n\n## Bug Feedback logs\n```text\n\n```\n\n# Format example\n## Code: snake.py\n```python\n## snake.py\n...\n```\n\n# Instruction: Based on the context, follow "Format example", write code.\n\n## Code: snake.py. Write code with triple quoto, based on the following attentions and context.\n1. Only One file: do your best to implement THIS ONLY ONE FILE.\n2. COMPLETE CODE: Your code will be part of the entire project, so please implement complete, reliable, reusable code snippets.\n3. Set default value: If there is any setting, ALWAYS SET A DEFAULT VALUE, ALWAYS USE STRONG TYPE AND EXPLICIT VARIABLE. AVOID circular import.\n4. Follow design: YOU MUST FOLLOW "Data structures and interfaces". DONT CHANGE ANY DESIGN. Do not use public member functions that do not exist in your design.\n5. CAREFULLY CHECK THAT YOU DONT MISS ANY NECESSARY CLASS/FUNCTION IN THIS FILE.\n6. Before using a external variable/module, make sure you import it first.\n7. Write out EVERY CODE DETAIL, DON\'T LEAVE TODO.\n\n'}]
2024-03-04 15:06:02.627 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.009 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.001, prompt_tokens: 848, completion_tokens: 317
4.2. Code Review 1
2024-03-04 15:06:02.629 | INFO | metagpt.actions.write_code_review:run:183 - Code review and rewrite snake.py: 1/2 | len(iterative_code)=1281, len(self.i_context.code_doc.content)=1281
2024-03-04 15:06:14.838 | DEBUG | metagpt.provider.base_llm:aask:88 - [{'role': 'system', 'content': 'You are a Engineer, named Alex, your goal is write elegant, readable, extensible, efficient code. the constraint is the code should conform to standards like google-style and be modular and maintainable. Use same language as user requirement. '}, {'role': 'user', 'content': '\n# System\nRole: You are a professional software engineer, and your main task is to review and revise the code. You need to ensure that the code conforms to the google-style standards, is elegantly designed and modularized, easy to read and maintain.\nLanguage: Please use the same language as the user requirement, but the title and code should be still in English. For example, if the user speaks Chinese, the specific text of your answer should also be in Chinese.\nATTENTION: Use \'##\' to SPLIT SECTIONS, not \'#\'. Output format carefully referenced "Format example".\n\n# Context\n## System Design\n{"Implementation approach":"We will use the Pygame library to create the snake game in Python. Pygame provides a simple and easy-to-use framework for game development, including handling keyboard inputs and rendering graphics.","File list":["main.py","game.py","snake.py","ui.py"],"Data structures and interfaces":"\\nclassDiagram\\n class Game {\\n -int score\\n -bool game_over\\n -Snake snake\\n +__init__()\\n +update()\\n +draw()\\n }\\n class Snake {\\n -list body\\n -str direction\\n +__init__()\\n +change_direction()\\n +move()\\n +eat()\\n }\\n class UI {\\n -Game game\\n +__init__()\\n +update_score()\\n +update_game_status()\\n +draw()\\n }\\n Game --> Snake\\n Game --> UI\\n","Program call flow":"\\nsequenceDiagram\\n participant M as Main\\n participant G as Game\\n participant S as Snake\\n participant U as UI\\n M->>G: __init__()\\n loop Game Loop\\n G->>S: update()\\n S->>S: move()\\n G->>U: update_score()\\n G->>U: update_game_status()\\n G->>G: draw()\\n end\\n","Anything UNCLEAR":""}\n\n## Task\n{"Required Python packages":["pygame==2.0.1"],"Required Other language third-party packages":["No third-party dependencies required"],"Logic Analysis":[["game.py","Contains Game class and ... functions"],["main.py","Contains main function, from game import Game"],["snake.py","Contains Snake class and ... functions"],["ui.py","Contains UI class and ... functions"]],"Task list":["game.py","snake.py","ui.py","main.py"],"Full API spec":"","Shared Knowledge":"`game.py` contains functions shared across the project.","Anything UNCLEAR":"Clarification needed on how to handle user inputs and render graphics using Pygame library."}\n\n## Code Files\n\n\n\n## Code to be Reviewed: snake.py\n```Code\n## snake.py\n\nclass Snake:\n def __init__(self):\n self.body = [(0, 0)] # Default starting position\n self.direction = "RIGHT" # Default direction\n\n def change_direction(self, new_direction):\n if new_direction in ["UP", "DOWN", "LEFT", "RIGHT"]:\n # Avoid reversing the snake\'s direction\n if (new_direction == "UP" and self.direction != "DOWN") or \\\n (new_direction == "DOWN" and self.direction != "UP") or \\\n (new_direction == "LEFT" and self.direction != "RIGHT") or \\\n (new_direction == "RIGHT" and self.direction != "LEFT"):\n self.direction = new_direction\n\n def move(self):\n head_x, head_y = self.body[0]\n if self.direction == "UP":\n new_head = (head_x, head_y - 1)\n elif self.direction == "DOWN":\n new_head = (head_x, head_y + 1)\n elif self.direction == "LEFT":\n new_head = (head_x - 1, head_y)\n elif self.direction == "RIGHT":\n new_head = (head_x + 1, head_y)\n self.body = [new_head] + self.body[:-1] # Move the snake by adding a new head and removing the tail\n\n def eat(self):\n # Logic for when the snake eats food, e.g., increasing the length of the snake\n pass\n\n```\n\n\n\n# Format example 1\n## Code Review: snake.py\n1. No, we should fix the logic of class A due to ...\n2. ...\n3. ...\n4. No, function B is not implemented, ...\n5. ...\n6. ...\n\n## Actions\n1. Fix the `handle_events` method to update the game state only if a move is successful.\n ```python\n def handle_events(self):\n for event in pygame.event.get():\n if event.type == pygame.QUIT:\n return False\n if event.type == pygame.KEYDOWN:\n moved = False\n if event.key == pygame.K_UP:\n moved = self.game.move(\'UP\')\n elif event.key == pygame.K_DOWN:\n moved = self.game.move(\'DOWN\')\n elif event.key == pygame.K_LEFT:\n moved = self.game.move(\'LEFT\')\n elif event.key == pygame.K_RIGHT:\n moved = self.game.move(\'RIGHT\')\n if moved:\n # Update the game state only if a move was successful\n self.render()\n return True\n ```\n2. Implement function B\n\n## Code Review Result\nLBTM\n\n# Format example 2\n## Code Review: snake.py\n1. Yes.\n2. Yes.\n3. Yes.\n4. Yes.\n5. Yes.\n6. Yes.\n\n## Actions\npass\n\n## Code Review Result\nLGTM\n\n\n\n# Instruction: Based on the actual code situation, follow one of the "Format example". Return only 1 file under review.\n\n## Code Review: Ordered List. Based on the "Code to be Reviewed", provide key, clear, concise, and specific answer. If any answer is no, explain how to fix it step by step.\n1. Is the code implemented as per the requirements? If not, how to achieve it? Analyse it step by step.\n2. Is the code logic completely correct? If there are errors, please indicate how to correct them.\n3. Does the existing code follow the "Data structures and interfaces"?\n4. Are all functions implemented? If there is no implementation, please indicate how to achieve it step by step.\n5. Have all necessary pre-dependencies been imported? If not, indicate which ones need to be imported\n6. Are methods from other files being reused correctly?\n\n## Actions: Ordered List. Things that should be done after CR, such as implementing class A and function B\n\n## Code Review Result: str. If the code doesn\'t have bugs, we don\'t need to rewrite it, so answer LGTM and stop. ONLY ANSWER LGTM/LBTM.\nLGTM/LBTM\n\n'}]
2024-03-04 15:06:17.606 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.011 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.002, prompt_tokens: 1491, completion_tokens: 208
4.3. Write Code 2
2024-03-04 15:06:25.056 | DEBUG | metagpt.provider.base_llm:aask:88 - [{'role': 'system', 'content': 'You are a Engineer, named Alex, your goal is write elegant, readable, extensible, efficient code. the constraint is the code should conform to standards like google-style and be modular and maintainable. Use same language as user requirement. '}, {'role': 'user', 'content': '\n# System\nRole: You are a professional software engineer, and your main task is to review and revise the code. You need to ensure that the code conforms to the google-style standards, is elegantly designed and modularized, easy to read and maintain.\nLanguage: Please use the same language as the user requirement, but the title and code should be still in English. For example, if the user speaks Chinese, the specific text of your answer should also be in Chinese.\nATTENTION: Use \'##\' to SPLIT SECTIONS, not \'#\'. Output format carefully referenced "Format example".\n\n# Context\n## System Design\n{"Implementation approach":"We will use the Pygame library to create the snake game in Python. Pygame provides a simple and easy-to-use framework for game development, including handling keyboard inputs and rendering graphics.","File list":["main.py","game.py","snake.py","ui.py"],"Data structures and interfaces":"\\nclassDiagram\\n class Game {\\n -int score\\n -bool game_over\\n -Snake snake\\n +__init__()\\n +update()\\n +draw()\\n }\\n class Snake {\\n -list body\\n -str direction\\n +__init__()\\n +change_direction()\\n +move()\\n +eat()\\n }\\n class UI {\\n -Game game\\n +__init__()\\n +update_score()\\n +update_game_status()\\n +draw()\\n }\\n Game --> Snake\\n Game --> UI\\n","Program call flow":"\\nsequenceDiagram\\n participant M as Main\\n participant G as Game\\n participant S as Snake\\n participant U as UI\\n M->>G: __init__()\\n loop Game Loop\\n G->>S: update()\\n S->>S: move()\\n G->>U: update_score()\\n G->>U: update_game_status()\\n G->>G: draw()\\n end\\n","Anything UNCLEAR":""}\n\n## Task\n{"Required Python packages":["pygame==2.0.1"],"Required Other language third-party packages":["No third-party dependencies required"],"Logic Analysis":[["game.py","Contains Game class and ... functions"],["main.py","Contains main function, from game import Game"],["snake.py","Contains Snake class and ... functions"],["ui.py","Contains UI class and ... functions"]],"Task list":["game.py","snake.py","ui.py","main.py"],"Full API spec":"","Shared Knowledge":"`game.py` contains functions shared across the project.","Anything UNCLEAR":"Clarification needed on how to handle user inputs and render graphics using Pygame library."}\n\n## Code Files\n\n\n\n## Code to be Reviewed: snake.py\n```Code\n## snake.py\n\nclass Snake:\n def __init__(self):\n self.body = [(0, 0)] # Default starting position\n self.direction = "RIGHT" # Default direction\n\n def change_direction(self, new_direction):\n if new_direction in ["UP", "DOWN", "LEFT", "RIGHT"]:\n # Avoid reversing the snake\'s direction\n if (new_direction == "UP" and self.direction != "DOWN") or \\\n (new_direction == "DOWN" and self.direction != "UP") or \\\n (new_direction == "LEFT" and self.direction != "RIGHT") or \\\n (new_direction == "RIGHT" and self.direction != "LEFT"):\n self.direction = new_direction\n\n def move(self):\n head_x, head_y = self.body[0]\n if self.direction == "UP":\n new_head = (head_x, head_y - 1)\n elif self.direction == "DOWN":\n new_head = (head_x, head_y + 1)\n elif self.direction == "LEFT":\n new_head = (head_x - 1, head_y)\n elif self.direction == "RIGHT":\n new_head = (head_x + 1, head_y)\n self.body = [new_head] + self.body[:-1] # Move the snake by adding a new head and removing the tail\n\n def eat(self):\n # Logic for when the snake eats food, e.g., increasing the length of the snake\n pass\n\n```\n\n## Code Review: snake.py\n1. Yes, the code is implemented as per the requirements. The Snake class is correctly initialized with default starting position and direction.\n2. Yes, the code logic is completely correct. The change_direction method correctly updates the direction of the snake, and the move method moves the snake in the correct direction.\n3. Yes, the existing code follows the "Data structures and interfaces" specified in the system design.\n4. No, the eat method is not implemented. To implement it, we need to define the logic for when the snake eats food, such as increasing the length of the snake. \n5. Yes, all necessary pre-dependencies have been imported. The code does not require any additional imports.\n6. Yes, the methods from other files are not being reused in this file.\n\n## Actions\n1. Implement the eat method in the Snake class to define the logic for when the snake eats food, e.g., increasing the length of the snake.\n\n## Code Review Result\nLBTM\n\n# Instruction: rewrite code based on the Code Review and Actions\n## Rewrite Code: CodeBlock. If it still has some bugs, rewrite snake.py with triple quotes. Do your utmost to optimize THIS SINGLE FILE. Return all completed codes and prohibit the return of unfinished codes.\n```Code\n## snake.py\n...\n```\n'}]
2024-03-04 15:06:30.031 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.013 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.002, prompt_tokens: 1227, completion_tokens: 338
4.4. Code Review 2
2024-03-04 15:06:45.878 | INFO | metagpt.actions.write_code_review:run:183 - Code review and rewrite snake.py: 2/2 | len(iterative_code)=1365, len(self.i_context.code_doc.content)=1281
2024-03-04 15:06:48.874 | DEBUG | metagpt.provider.base_llm:aask:88 - [{'role': 'system', 'content': 'You are a Engineer, named Alex, your goal is write elegant, readable, extensible, efficient code. the constraint is the code should conform to standards like google-style and be modular and maintainable. Use same language as user requirement. '}, {'role': 'user', 'content': '\n# System\nRole: You are a professional software engineer, and your main task is to review and revise the code. You need to ensure that the code conforms to the google-style standards, is elegantly designed and modularized, easy to read and maintain.\nLanguage: Please use the same language as the user requirement, but the title and code should be still in English. For example, if the user speaks Chinese, the specific text of your answer should also be in Chinese.\nATTENTION: Use \'##\' to SPLIT SECTIONS, not \'#\'. Output format carefully referenced "Format example".\n\n# Context\n## System Design\n{"Implementation approach":"We will use the Pygame library to create the snake game in Python. Pygame provides a simple and easy-to-use framework for game development, including handling keyboard inputs and rendering graphics.","File list":["main.py","game.py","snake.py","ui.py"],"Data structures and interfaces":"\\nclassDiagram\\n class Game {\\n -int score\\n -bool game_over\\n -Snake snake\\n +__init__()\\n +update()\\n +draw()\\n }\\n class Snake {\\n -list body\\n -str direction\\n +__init__()\\n +change_direction()\\n +move()\\n +eat()\\n }\\n class UI {\\n -Game game\\n +__init__()\\n +update_score()\\n +update_game_status()\\n +draw()\\n }\\n Game --> Snake\\n Game --> UI\\n","Program call flow":"\\nsequenceDiagram\\n participant M as Main\\n participant G as Game\\n participant S as Snake\\n participant U as UI\\n M->>G: __init__()\\n loop Game Loop\\n G->>S: update()\\n S->>S: move()\\n G->>U: update_score()\\n G->>U: update_game_status()\\n G->>G: draw()\\n end\\n","Anything UNCLEAR":""}\n\n## Task\n{"Required Python packages":["pygame==2.0.1"],"Required Other language third-party packages":["No third-party dependencies required"],"Logic Analysis":[["game.py","Contains Game class and ... functions"],["main.py","Contains main function, from game import Game"],["snake.py","Contains Snake class and ... functions"],["ui.py","Contains UI class and ... functions"]],"Task list":["game.py","snake.py","ui.py","main.py"],"Full API spec":"","Shared Knowledge":"`game.py` contains functions shared across the project.","Anything UNCLEAR":"Clarification needed on how to handle user inputs and render graphics using Pygame library."}\n\n## Code Files\n\n\n\n## Code to be Reviewed: snake.py\n```Code\n## snake.py\n\nclass Snake:\n def __init__(self):\n self.body = [(0, 0)] # Default starting position\n self.direction = "RIGHT" # Default direction\n\n def change_direction(self, new_direction):\n if new_direction in ["UP", "DOWN", "LEFT", "RIGHT"]:\n # Avoid reversing the snake\'s direction\n if (new_direction == "UP" and self.direction != "DOWN") or \\\n (new_direction == "DOWN" and self.direction != "UP") or \\\n (new_direction == "LEFT" and self.direction != "RIGHT") or \\\n (new_direction == "RIGHT" and self.direction != "LEFT"):\n self.direction = new_direction\n\n def move(self):\n head_x, head_y = self.body[0]\n if self.direction == "UP":\n new_head = (head_x, head_y - 1)\n elif self.direction == "DOWN":\n new_head = (head_x, head_y + 1)\n elif self.direction == "LEFT":\n new_head = (head_x - 1, head_y)\n elif self.direction == "RIGHT":\n new_head = (head_x + 1, head_y)\n self.body = [new_head] + self.body[:-1] # Move the snake by adding a new head and removing the tail\n\n def eat(self):\n # Logic for when the snake eats food, e.g., increasing the length of the snake\n self.body.append(self.body[-1]) # Increase the length of the snake by adding a new tail\n\n```\n\n\n\n# Format example 1\n## Code Review: snake.py\n1. No, we should fix the logic of class A due to ...\n2. ...\n3. ...\n4. No, function B is not implemented, ...\n5. ...\n6. ...\n\n## Actions\n1. Fix the `handle_events` method to update the game state only if a move is successful.\n ```python\n def handle_events(self):\n for event in pygame.event.get():\n if event.type == pygame.QUIT:\n return False\n if event.type == pygame.KEYDOWN:\n moved = False\n if event.key == pygame.K_UP:\n moved = self.game.move(\'UP\')\n elif event.key == pygame.K_DOWN:\n moved = self.game.move(\'DOWN\')\n elif event.key == pygame.K_LEFT:\n moved = self.game.move(\'LEFT\')\n elif event.key == pygame.K_RIGHT:\n moved = self.game.move(\'RIGHT\')\n if moved:\n # Update the game state only if a move was successful\n self.render()\n return True\n ```\n2. Implement function B\n\n## Code Review Result\nLBTM\n\n# Format example 2\n## Code Review: snake.py\n1. Yes.\n2. Yes.\n3. Yes.\n4. Yes.\n5. Yes.\n6. Yes.\n\n## Actions\npass\n\n## Code Review Result\nLGTM\n\n\n\n# Instruction: Based on the actual code situation, follow one of the "Format example". Return only 1 file under review.\n\n## Code Review: Ordered List. Based on the "Code to be Reviewed", provide key, clear, concise, and specific answer. If any answer is no, explain how to fix it step by step.\n1. Is the code implemented as per the requirements? If not, how to achieve it? Analyse it step by step.\n2. Is the code logic completely correct? If there are errors, please indicate how to correct them.\n3. Does the existing code follow the "Data structures and interfaces"?\n4. Are all functions implemented? If there is no implementation, please indicate how to achieve it step by step.\n5. Have all necessary pre-dependencies been imported? If not, indicate which ones need to be imported\n6. Are methods from other files being reused correctly?\n\n## Actions: Ordered List. Things that should be done after CR, such as implementing class A and function B\n\n## Code Review Result: str. If the code doesn\'t have bugs, we don\'t need to rewrite it, so answer LGTM and stop. ONLY ANSWER LGTM/LBTM.\nLGTM/LBTM\n\n'}]
2024-03-04 15:06:51.904 | INFO | metagpt.utils.cost_manager:update_cost:52 - Total running cost: $0.015 | Max budget: $10.000 | Current cost: $0.002, prompt_tokens: 1511, completion_tokens: 161
2024-03-04 15:07:14.136 | INFO | metagpt.utils.file_repository:save:60 - save to: /Users/iorishinier/github/bak/MetaGPT/workspace/snake_python/snake_python/snake.py
2024-03-04 15:07:14.144 | INFO | metagpt.utils.file_repository:save:65 - update dependency: /Users/iorishinier/github/bak/MetaGPT/workspace/snake_python/snake_python/snake.py:{'docs/task/20240304150313.json', 'docs/system_design/20240304150313.json'}
5. Write ui.py
2024-03-04 15:07:37.784 | INFO | metagpt.actions.write_code:run:147 - Writing ui.py..
Hi @iorisa ,
Thank you for your reply!
The issues and my thoughts are here:
Issues:
- The Engineer Agent decided to rewrite the code after QA Engineer reported LGTM (It shows no issue in QAE's report, but Engineer Agent did the rewrite). Could you please tell me what is the stop condition for write_code_review
- The total running cost seems to be reset at step1, step2, step3 and step 4. I marked them in Bold.
Thoughts: Regarding issue 1, GPT-4-turbo cases did not produce the same error. I think I downloaded a version 0.7 in February. Not sure if I can check the version on my local drive. Issue 1 is hard to reproduce and only occurs when I use gpt-3.5-turbo-16k-0613. There could be something there, but I'm not sure. If there's any ways to trigger that again, I'll see if I can provide more information.
Regarding issue 2, is it possible to produce a clarification? Is the cost_manager calculates based on phases or based on the whole process? And it could also be a good idea to count the cumulated token spent for prompt and completion tokens.
Thank you again for your help.
@Coppelian Thanks for the question. Problem 1 looks really strange, and I haven't reproduced it yet; as for problem 2, there is only one global meter by design, but there may be some bugs in a previous version, but on the main branch, this problem It should have been fixed
@Coppelian Thanks for the question. Problem 1 looks really strange, and I haven't reproduced it yet; as for problem 2, there is only one global meter by design, but there may be some bugs in a previous version, but on the main branch, this problem It should have been fixed
Thanks a lot for your reply! I'll close this issue later.