Gilles Colling comments

Results 7 comments of


                                            Gilles Colling

Filtering: (Long comments should be excluded in auto-smart mode)

> I mean long =/= not spam. This looks like a false positive yes but there are still long comments that are spam that do get caught regularly. The comment...

[REVIEW]: corrselect: Exhaustive variable subset selection based on correlation and association matrices

Thanks for the question. The version submitted for review is 2.0.1. Since submitting, I have continued development and added new functions and a user interface, which are included in the...

[REVIEW]: corrselect: Exhaustive variable subset selection based on correlation and association matrices

Thanks, that works for me. What is the correct procedure on the JOSS side for updating the submission? Should I tag a new release and update the paper in the...

[REVIEW]: corrselect: Exhaustive variable subset selection based on correlation and association matrices

Version 3.0.2, which is the latest cran version. I updated the paper.md file accordingly

[REVIEW]: corrselect: Exhaustive variable subset selection based on correlation and association matrices

Thank you for the thorough and constructive review. I have addressed all points raised. ## 1. JOSS Requirements **Comparison with State-of-the-Art** The comparison with *caret* has been strengthened in the...

[REVIEW]: corrselect: Exhaustive variable subset selection based on correlation and association matrices

@danStich Thanks for letting me know :)

[REVIEW]: corrselect: Exhaustive variable subset selection based on correlation and association matrices

@danStich Thanks for the thorough review and for testing the package with your own datasets. It's great to hear it's been useful, and I appreciate the perspective :) I've replied...