opendbc icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
opendbc copied to clipboard

doco/website: Add footnote to VW-group cars to prevent user confusion about where harness connects (option 2 - brand-specific footnote)

Open borhub opened this issue 2 months ago • 2 comments

Follow-up from https://github.com/commaai/openpilot/pull/36325

The Comma website is missing information for VW car users informing them that the J533 harness doesn't connect to the usual location on the windshield camera as advertised on the Comma website. This omission caused users to be confused and their Comma installation delayed when the harness connector didn't match the camera connector which they expected to plug into. People think they got the wrong connector, have to go to Discord etc.

This change fixes the customer experience by adding a footnote that directs the users to connect to the correct module under the dash.


The brand-specific copy solution option here leads to creation of more footnotes in CARS.md as more footnotes are added into respective brands' values.py files, but it gives the customer a clearer guidance about where to plug the harness, likely reducing some Discord back-and-forths, consumers sending devices back etc. The CARS.md would end up with one footnote for each brand, but this might be a good tradeoff for getting greater end-customer clarity on the website. The brand-agnostic, more generic copy alternative is in PR https://github.com/commaai/opendbc/pull/2841

borhub avatar Oct 15 '25 11:10 borhub

a good idea! thought of sending it back because of this. limited in tools, I am not able to install it currently. already spent time on this. honestly I wouldn't have bought it in the first place if I knew that beforehand. definitely needs to be added on the homepage

speedyconzales avatar Oct 31 '25 15:10 speedyconzales

@sshane @adeebshihadeh From a product owner lens, are you happy to merge this in and propagate the resulting CARS.md into the openpilot repo and then (the ultimate goal) to the website repo, so that the website has the additional footnote?

Note there's a 2nd variant of this PR that has a more generic implementation that could be used for multiple brands (but we'd need a more generic text) https://github.com/commaai/opendbc/pull/2841 I think either would improve the customer experience a lot and avoid surprises and confusion.

(Note: I haven't actually built the CARS.md as I don't know the process - being a Python newb - but static analysis seems happy, so hopefully the code will work as is)

borhub avatar Nov 05 '25 05:11 borhub

We have a few harnesses like this, if you think this disproportionally affects VW for some reason, we can merge this now. Just needs some clean up

sshane avatar Nov 11 '25 09:11 sshane