Chantel Wetzel

I think this expanded output is relatively clear and includes all the needed information. Thanks!

Thanks for looking into this issue. I typically always run the safe executable. There is a potential "urban legend" story that I heard of someone using only the opt executable...

As the developer and maintainer of the nwfscDiag package, I would redirect that time to assist in supporting ss3diags generally and ensuring that it provides needed items for U.S. West...

I completely agree. I think having an item in the SS_output list (i.e. $param_offset that would just read the setting as 0 or 1) could be used as a switch...

This new output would have really come in handy for sablefish since there were multiple questions about the proportion of the population mature vs. immature given the recent high recruitments....

I think we could also collapse the numbers-at-age matrix across ages since that is already outputted to calculate the percent mature in numbers. I think providing this in terms of...

I agree that removing this option is the simplest approach to ensure that the produced tables work.

Since Jim' image did not upload correctly, here it is again: [mod_fsh_sel.pdf](https://github.com/r4ss/r4ss/files/3382672/mod_fsh_sel.pdf)

I don't have much to add here because I think the main issues have been well covered by both of you. However, I would suggest that we could deal with...

I agree adding units here would be beneficial. This is straight-forward for model in biomass. However, I need to look at the r4ss code to see if @iantaylor-NOAA have figured...