Arfon Smith
Arfon Smith
@editorialbot add @acrlakshman as reviewer
@gflofst, @acrlakshman – This is the review thread for the paper. All of our communications will happen here from now on. Please read the "Reviewer instructions & questions" in the...
:wave: @acrlakshman – just checking in here. Do you think you might be able to start your review soon?
> @arfon I need to go through the technical details. At first glance, the submitting author (@rico-berner) did not make significant contributions to the software, however the author list looks...
@xuanxu – looks like @editorialbot is failing to find the correct checklist when starting these reviews: ``` 2023-08-13T07:05:47.372267+00:00 app[web.1]: W, [2023-08-13T07:05:47.372174 #8] WARN -- : Error calling ReviewerChecklistCommentResponder: GET https://api.github.com/repos/openjournals/jose-reviews/contents/.buffy/templates/reviewer_checklist.md:...
Quick update, I emailed @ivirshup earlier today to see when they might be able to provide updates.
@Fei-Tao as it looks like @Annielytix isn't going to be able to complete a timely review, I suggest removing them from the reviewer list. You can do that with `@editorialbot...
> However in the absence of a JOSS definition of paper authorship, I can only go by definitions of other respected organisations. I believe there is a third way here...
> I think it would be useful to have this documented so that we have a clear reference to point authors to who would be interested. Do people agree? Yes,...
I think because the database is broken? (Waiting on some support from @xuanxu on this)