Pascal Obry

Where the initial proposal fails short is that on most Open Source projects people like to hack something before proposing a PR. When the PR is created we do discuss......

> Do we find this acceptable? This is what I'd hope to combat. In addition, 11 years into the project, we should be aiming more for refinement of our UX/UI,...

> Or we reverse the situation and say that if nobody says it's a good idea after three weeks it gets dropped. That's already the case, no? I do merge...

> If that fails, should we at least set the expectation with people who raise a PR that there will be scrutiny (up to and including nonconstructive "this isn't good")....

> If you think what has been happening lately is the best we can do, I feel that, maybe not the best way of working, but the best I can...

https://github.com/darktable-org/rawspeed/pull/388 (merged in develop not yet in stable branch).

@flannelhead : Do you think you'll have time to handle this for 4.2?

> I can try to take a look at it during November. Failing that, I would suggest just reverting the PR #12233 and accepting the black pixels. Will do that.

@gi-man : That's a sensible view... @flannelhead is you final view a revert? In both cases we have an issue anyway. I have no strong opinion, maybe leaning slightly toward...

> Did I get something wrong? No I did exactly that and I tried 3 times. I had to kill dt as it was locked somehow. I then reverted the...