Chris Blume
Chris Blume
@jbowler please be more respectful. "fallacious" and "you don't understand private vs public chunk handling" are pushing it. Let's walk through the scenario where we make APNG chunks public. First,...
This feels like a tricky one. For typical computer use cases today, all images will be full range. In fact, I think even an (non-broadcast) expert would need to work...
Just to be clear, I think "...completely define the tone mapping algorithm..." might just mean the decoder's choice of tone mapping is now set, right? IE we aren't defining what...
It shouldn't. It's more like when mDCv and cLLI are present, the decoder has everything it needs to make a consistent decision about which tone mapping to use. I think...
It is a little tricky because the HDR metadata in cLLi is itself dependent on the image contents. I could imagine a scenario where a new tone mapping algorithm is...
I'm going to close this issue because I believe the current spec wording is correct. Feel free to comment and re-open if we find an encoder that saves eXIf after...
Friendly ping: There are changes requested in order for this patch to land.
In our last meeting, we mentioned that the two open pull requests (this is one of them) are for Fourth Edition. But I think we said that wrong. I think...
I believe this is now ready to land. I'll add my approval. But please review my changes and confirm you're happy with them.
Friendly ping @chrisn -- Does this work for you?