pcl icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
pcl copied to clipboard

[io] Add PCL grabber for ZED Stereo Camera

Open shrijitsingh99 opened this issue 4 years ago • 5 comments

ZED Stereo cameras have become quite popular and used by quite a lot of people. Adding its support would be a great feature to have.

Context

Currently, OpenNI and RealSense devices are only supported by PCL. It makes sense to have ZED too, it's as popular as the above two. It would be great if we could have a standard API to access all these devices. Usage of these devices through this API would reduce redundancy and help avoid bad practices that are inherent when users try to write their own grabber.

Expected behavior

Similar to current implementations of OpenNI and RealSense devices. ZED already has examples to get started with this.

Current Behavior

Doesn't exist. Have to write your own grabber using ZED API.

Describe the solution you'd like

A wrapper over ZED API having an interface similar to wrappers for existing devices.

Describe alternatives you've considered

One question that comes to mind is slightly opposite to the proposed idea is that, do such wrappers need to exist or should be removed from PCL and be left to the respective manufacturers to provide interfaces and users write their own wrappers, instead of bloating PCL. Maintaining such a codebase is also an issue as it requires access to physical hardware.

shrijitsingh99 avatar Mar 17 '20 11:03 shrijitsingh99

They also have an example using PCL.

larshg avatar Mar 17 '20 11:03 larshg

They also have an example using PCL.

Yeah, shouldn't require much effort to build a similar interface like for other devices.

shrijitsingh99 avatar Mar 17 '20 13:03 shrijitsingh99

In general I like to get some notion of how popular some of these cameras are among our user base before adding grabber implementations. How about we start a "head count" by having interested users "like" the OP?

It's the first time I hear about ZED stereo cameras. Are there any public robotics/computer vision datasets acquired with these?

SergioRAgostinho avatar Mar 18 '20 07:03 SergioRAgostinho

Marking this as stale due to 30 days of inactivity. It will be closed in 7 days if no further activity occurs.

stale[bot] avatar May 19 '20 06:05 stale[bot]

I use a ZED camera. The examples that they have provided are good and works well. Is there any advantage of adding direct support in PCL itself? As mentioned in the first comment, maintaining these wrappers would require physical access to hardware, and I kinda agree with idea of the company behind ZED maintain those wrappers.

aditya369007 avatar Nov 15 '21 02:11 aditya369007