Paul Licameli

> Why are they modal? They weren't modal in 3.1.3. And the designs show the user doing stuff with the UI while the effect settings are open. Non-modal dialogs are...

I observe that when opening the dialog from the sidebar, there is no button to close it other than the top bar decorations added by the operating system, shown here...

So if I try settings changes, listen, don't like them, and just want to revert them all as they were -- then there is no way but to reset all...

In my opinion the extra effort to implement the Esc key would be worth the effort as a later enhancement, if not a necessity for the release. I say this...

"When the dialog is closed unexpectedly" So we could revert only in response to an explicit user action 🤷

> Yes, a lot of VST plugins will have an 'Init preset' (init short for initialized) which means resetting plugin back to default. "Back to default" is not the same...

I found unintended mouse drags of all kinds to be bothersome and make Esc cancel them all, because there are often many things you can click and drag and you...

Okay, forget about Esc, if we suppose it's not like mouse drags. But a different question is whether to "ModifyState" of the Undo stack. If I fiddle with settings, Undo,...

I think this bug is not new in 3.2. Can you confirm that it happened also in 3.1.3?

> > I think this bug is not new in 3.2. Can you confirm that it happened also in 3.1.3? > > I can't test Freeverb in Audacity 3.1.3 because...