Jeremy Rubin

Leaning towards nack, there's an infinitude of things not committed to, it's better to read the spec of what is comitted. On Mon, Jul 17, 2023, 8:40 PM Luke Dashjr...

The BIP currently has this text: > The set of data committed to is a superset of data which can impact the TXID of the transaction, other than the inputs.

I'll defer this decision to the editing team, I don't really know who or what audience bips are ultimately for. The change at least seems accurate to me On Thu,...

tbh i have no idea how to read that table, so might be good to have clearer labeling somehow / break down where the accounting came from?

I get that there is a goal here to avoid introspection... but it seems that it'd be more generically useful if the function were e.g., a TapBranch function, so then...

I think it's actually *less* controversial, because if you do `OP_TAPBRANCHCOMMIT` you're doing something that even once you have OP_CAT, is really handy to have (because sorting two strings is...

Reviewed, code seems correct and to match the old prs closely. cr ACK [2b74adf](https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/pull/31989/commits/2b74adfb2001949c8f2bba17e5991aebd426127d) will re-review as necessary

i was looking into how runes could be etched into CTV addresses and distributed e.g. over time. Otherwise, you need to premine, wait for confirmation, and then trustedly send the...

> An issue with EcMath is that the amount of code that needs to be introduced to bitcoind can be enormous. > > This was one of the reasons why...

No, the intent for EcMath is to be able to compute taproot key tweaks and other key derivation stuff... not sure that we'd want to support arbitrary curves? cc @apoelstra...