Bukhtawar Khan

> And so the existing shard allocation system that ES uses, will be no worse in OS/segrep, it's just that many nodes will be substantially under-loaded since they are no...

>Primary Selection - We want to update the selection of a new primary to choose the furthest ahead replica. This is defined as a replica that has the latest available...

> > Do you think we could add tests to exercise the new code path? Will review in details once we add tests and resolve conflicts. At this point the...

The problem doing a dry-run is we would usually go with an optimistic locking approach assuming that between the dry-run and the actual call nothing else has changes. However it...

> The only trade-off I see is that changes might take longer to be available on all replicas. We might have to implement this in a way that replica doesn't...

This is specific to Amazon OpenSearch Service which has been well documented here https://docs.aws.amazon.com/opensearch-service/latest/developerguide/supported-operations.html#version_7_10

Lets link this with #12683

> > Would appreciate any initial feedback from @shwetathareja, @nknize, @Bukhtawar, @sachinpkale, @muralikpbhat, @reta, @msfroh and @backslasht as well, so tagging more folks for visibility. Thanks! > > Thanks @RS146BIJAY...

I echo my thoughts with @reta and had similar comments on labelling this as "sandbox" since this is more a tenant specific resource limit. While this is a good starting...

Thanks @msfroh I like the proposal where it says the tags/identity etc aren't mutually exclusive. We can define ways to define an identity or a user-label or for that matter...