typescript icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
typescript copied to clipboard

Test Different Scenarios

Open hifabienne opened this issue 1 year ago • 3 comments

General

  • [ ] The login feels pretty slow, i do see some screens sometimes, which then are skiped because some informations already exist, e.g login hint, first to second screen
  • [x] Error messages are not human readable, its always a server error

Bugs

  • [x] Redirect to app doesn't work after user registration image

  • [x] Reset Password click results in error image

  • [x] When redirecting to the login with an org scope, and entering a user from the wrong organization, I get an error message which doesn't help me anything image

  • [x] When a error occures, I can't do anything afterwards, continue button loads, and back doesn't work image

  • [x] When sending a org scope and clicking on register new user, i loose the context of the org and be on the default org again

  • [x] If i have enforced mfa, i can skip it and login without mfa

  • [x] MFA setup doesn't show what i have configured on my organization, it always shows passkey

  • [x] if password hide is enabled, password reset is still shown on the password screen

  • [x] if "ignore unknown username" is enabled, i still get an error if the username could not be found

  • [ ] Per default the settings of the default organization should be triggered and not the instance settings

Improvements

  • [x] After registering a new user with username password I want to be authenticated directly, so i don't have to reenter username password again
  • [ ] If username password needs to entered again, I want the loginname to be prefilled
  • [ ] when i redirect to the login, and get the username screen, i have a back button, which doesn't make anything, I think the back button is useless in that case or should redirect back to the app
  • [ ] Should error message differ when user is locked? I always get password could not be verified
  • [ ] Default behaviour is not always the same, sometimes i am per default on the username screen and sometimes on the select account screen

hifabienne avatar Sep 09 '24 14:09 hifabienne

Registration:

  • Register User with Username Password
  • Register User with Passkey
  • Register User with External IPD

Login:

  • Login with username & password, mfa forced, but not registered
  • Login with username & password, hide password reset

Prompts

  • select_account
  • create
  • login
  • none

Scopes:

  • org id scope

Password Lockout:

  • Set password to 3 times, user should be locked

hifabienne avatar Sep 10 '24 11:09 hifabienne

"If i have enforced mfa, i can skip it and login without mfa" and "MFA setup doesn't show what i have configured on my organization, it always shows passkey" I guess you ment the prompt to setup passkeys. this shows up, when passkeys are enabled in the login settings. I have changed the priority to setup MFA before hinting to setup passkeys now.

peintnermax avatar Sep 20 '24 08:09 peintnermax

"Per default the settings of the default organization should be triggered and not the instance settings" this can be implemented after: https://github.com/zitadel/zitadel/issues/8616

peintnermax avatar Sep 20 '24 08:09 peintnermax

@peintnermax should we close this issue for now as i did a new test? #199

hifabienne avatar Oct 25 '24 09:10 hifabienne

i close it for now, let me know if we need to reopen

hifabienne avatar Nov 20 '24 11:11 hifabienne