butter icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
butter copied to clipboard

Consider a different name

Open FlyinPancake opened this issue 3 years ago • 10 comments

Describe the problem your feature would solve

There is a project called butter that is a btrfs subvolume manager. The clashing names can be confusing for some.

Describe the solution you'd like

A discussion about possible names for this project :smile:

FlyinPancake avatar Aug 23 '22 09:08 FlyinPancake

what about the name 'snapshots'

allaeddineomc avatar Aug 23 '22 10:08 allaeddineomc

Or btrsnapshots? It's not taken yet, and makes it clear it's a btrfs project and targeting snapshots.

TimLovesTech avatar Aug 23 '22 16:08 TimLovesTech

While not perfect, Butter is kinda okay as the other butter is written in shell scripts while Butter is a GUI application. The other butter also hasn't been updated for quite some time and is not packaged on most distros that I'm aware of.

Butter also owns some directories such as /etc/butter to store schedule rules, so changing the name can be complicated.

All that being said, I'm not totally against a new name for better discoverability, but it should be worth it. It should at least:

  • be composed of a single word
  • follow GNOME HIG
  • I hope for this app to become a superset of the btrfs utilities, not scoped to just snapshots.

My smol brain hasn't found a better name back then. 😝

zhangyuannie avatar Aug 24 '22 05:08 zhangyuannie

You could go for something like "margarine" or "shortening", or an object like "churner"?

andyholmes avatar Aug 24 '22 06:08 andyholmes

"Cadience" (not a real word, but a play on the root word)

(not to be confused with Cadence, which happens to be some Uber service)

It's not butter or milk related, but with the recent Gradience libadwaita tool, I think it has a nice similarity, but different touch to it and Cadence isn't named after anything as far as I can tell. Just my 2 cents. I'm sure there's far better names, but honestly I still happen to like Butter.

Scotty-Trees avatar Aug 24 '22 23:08 Scotty-Trees

"Cadience" (not a real word, but a play on the root word)

Yeah, searching Cadience on Google yield Cadence directly. The squiggly red line from auto correct doesn't help either. Ideally, it should be a real noun per HIG.

It's not butter or milk related

Doesn't have to honestly. I guess it just has to relate to subvolume/partition/disk management in general.

I still happen to like Butter.

Same, feel like it flows better.

zhangyuannie avatar Aug 25 '22 04:08 zhangyuannie

what about "cow" as in copy on write ? or maybe "butterknife" ?

allaeddineomc avatar Aug 25 '22 08:08 allaeddineomc

What about btrsnaps?

ghost avatar Oct 16 '22 10:10 ghost

How about btrshots?

iitzrohan avatar Oct 03 '23 07:10 iitzrohan

The name, icon and vibe fits GNOME perfectly, don't change a thing!

deusnovus avatar Oct 13 '23 14:10 deusnovus