SmartTube icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
SmartTube copied to clipboard

Clarification request about version 30.56

Open musicadi opened this issue 3 weeks ago • 127 comments

Checklist

  • [x] I made sure that there are no existing issues - open or closed - which I could contribute my information to.
  • [x] I have read the FAQ and my problem isn't listed.
  • [x] I have taken the time to fill in all the required details. I understand that the bug report will be dismissed otherwise.
  • [x] This issue contains only one bug.

Affected version

30.56

Device Type

Smart TV/Box

Affected Android

Android TV 9

Steps to reproduce the bug

  1. Check releases on Github - latest stable 30.48
  2. Check latest stable from official website - 30.56

Actual behavior

@yuliskov I’m aware you have enough to do now, but could you maybe clarify the versions mismatch, so everyone can be a bit more relaxed? :)

Yesterday, the Beta from my MiBox 3 was automatically removed, so I went to the official website (https://smarttubeapp.github.io/) and downloaded the latest stable, which worked. I was even able to restore from Google Drive backup.

Then, I checked the version, and it was 30.56, which was weird, since here on Github, latest stable is 30.48 before your notification, and on my MiBox 4, I have the stable version 30.19, but I never received an update notification for 30.20 or later (I have update check turned on).

Thank you, and I hope this will be sorted, so everyone can continue enjoying Youtube without having ads pushed down our throats or worrying about malicious actors having taken over.

Additional information

No response

musicadi avatar Nov 29 '25 06:11 musicadi

I'm confused as to what's going on to, I have version 30.55 installed but the latest version on here is 30.54. Then there's everyone talking about a version 30.56 which you can only get from some shortened link on the website?

aramaziakin avatar Nov 29 '25 08:11 aramaziakin

I'm confused as to what's going on to, I have version 30.55 installed but the latest version on here is 30.54. Then there's everyone talking about a version 30.56 which you can only get from some shortened link on the website?

Yes, that's where I downloaded it from. Checked it using virustototal.com and it says it's clean

https://www.virustotal.com/gui/file/57a62473186491d07687be8728b0e8aeed1770d280c83d21cc5464dddb058d1b

musicadi avatar Nov 29 '25 09:11 musicadi

Why is here no APK on GitHub to 30.56? Deactivating comments on telegram channel creates only more questions here.

lucai9000 avatar Nov 29 '25 09:11 lucai9000

30.56 is the absolute latest with the new digital signature (thus, future updates are enabled)

bzaconsulting23-jpg avatar Nov 29 '25 10:11 bzaconsulting23-jpg

No apk on github, telegram channel does not let you comment, but you get a captcha you have to reply to within 60 seconds, which you can't, so you get banned.

Downloader App, with the 28544 code, does not work and gives an error.

Is this project done for?

fbnkrs avatar Nov 29 '25 12:11 fbnkrs

Why is here no APK on GitHub to 30.56? Deactivating comments on telegram channel creates only more questions here.

There are links on the main page. Look for

The app has a built-in updater with changelog. You can also find all releases and the changelog on the Telegram channel @SmartTubeNewsEN (readable without account) or on Github.

latest beta download

latest stable download

https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTube/releases/download/latest/smarttube_beta.apk

https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTube/releases/download/latest/smarttube_stable.apk

dak151 avatar Nov 29 '25 12:11 dak151

30.56 is the absolute latest with the new digital signature (thus, future updates are enabled)

Yes, that's what I downloaded from the official site, as mentioned in my post. That was not my question though.

musicadi avatar Nov 29 '25 12:11 musicadi

No apk on github, telegram channel does not let you comment, but you get a captcha you have to reply to within 60 seconds, which you can't, so you get banned.

Downloader App does not work and gives an error.

Is this project done for?

Weird

musicadi avatar Nov 29 '25 12:11 musicadi

Downloader App, with the 28544 code, does not work and gives an error.

The Downloader App codes redirect to:

https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTubeNext/releases/download/latest/smarttube_stable.apk

instead of:

https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTube/releases/download/latest/smarttube_stable.apk

fbnkrs avatar Nov 29 '25 12:11 fbnkrs

Why is here no APK on GitHub to 30.56? Deactivating comments on telegram channel creates only more questions here.

There are links on the main page. Look for

The app has a built-in updater with changelog. You can also find all releases and the changelog on the Telegram channel @SmartTubeNewsEN (readable without account) or on Github.

latest beta download

latest stable download

https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTube/releases/download/latest/smarttube_beta.apk

https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTube/releases/download/latest/smarttube_stable.apk

Thank you! Can you confirm the stable from this link is 30.56?

Just because under releases, latest stable is 30.48, so maybe this link will download that one.

https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTube/releases

musicadi avatar Nov 29 '25 12:11 musicadi

Downloader App, with the 28544 code, does not work and gives an error.

The Downloader App codes redirect to:

https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTubeNext/releases/download/latest/smarttube_stable.apk

instead of:

https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTube/releases/download/latest/smarttube_stable.apk

I think a while ago, the app name was changed from SmartTube to SmartTubeNext, but I guess it was changed back, and maybe the code wasn't refreshed.

https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTubeNext/releases is actually redirected to https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTube/releases

So, basically the downloader is being redirected to the current site.

musicadi avatar Nov 29 '25 13:11 musicadi

Question. I have not installed the new signature test version of the beta build or stable build, that's because, to my surprise, the old stable build (with the old signature), is still actually working perfectly fine on my Firestick.

Should I be installing the new signature test version via beta or stable right now anyway? Or can I afford to wait until the old stable build stops working?

sliceanddice9 avatar Nov 29 '25 14:11 sliceanddice9

yes, you can keep it unless the PlayProtection is on. And don't forget to backup the data to easily move to the new one

Regards, Yuriy

On Sat, Nov 29, 2025, 16:28 sliceanddice9 @.***> wrote:

sliceanddice9 left a comment (yuliskov/SmartTube#5142) https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTube/issues/5142#issuecomment-3591715791

Question. I have not installed the new signature test version of the beta build or stable build, that's because, to my surprise, the old build (with the old signature), is still actually working perfectly fine on my Firestick.

Should I be installing the new signature test version via beta or stable right now anyway? Or can I afford to wait until the old build actually does stop functioning?

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTube/issues/5142#issuecomment-3591715791, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ABM7Z6CF2DHQWIQUS24O2DL37GUPJAVCNFSM6AAAAACNQ22UEGVHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43OSLTON2WKQ3PNVWWK3TUHMZTKOJRG4YTKNZZGE . You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: @.***>

yuliskov avatar Nov 29 '25 14:11 yuliskov

This was posted on the patreon forum..

_I have version 30.55 was version this yours?

AUTHOR

· 2d

yes. the latest that was created with the current key. there will be no more updates to it._

I had 20.79 stored in my shield folder, installed that and it is working fine :)

marker197 avatar Nov 29 '25 16:11 marker197

All fine now. I got the latest 30.56. it would be better when it would be also under GitHub releases section, just like it always was and not only on this special site.

lucai9000 avatar Nov 29 '25 16:11 lucai9000

yes, you can keep it unless the PlayProtection is on. And don't forget to backup the data to easily move to the new one

Regards, Yuriy

So we're just going to ignore being transparent what happened with the original signing key?

I for one cannot trust any of the new versions until we can confirm your GitHub account (and Patreon) weren't compromised along with the old digital signature. (And in my eyes, neither should others, if they're sensible about it.)

Please update us with a transparent disclosure on the topic.

  1. What happened to the original signing key?
  2. Do you know how it got leaked?
  3. Do you know when it got leaked?
  4. What steps are you taking to assure this won't happen in the future?
  5. Can you somehow verify that you, are indeed still yuliskov, and not some malicious actor?

codevogel avatar Nov 29 '25 17:11 codevogel

Please update us with a transparent disclosure on the topic.

  1. What happened to the original signing key?
  2. Do you know how it got leaked?
  3. Do you know when it got leaked?
  4. What steps are you taking to assure this won't happen in the future?
  5. Can you somehow verify that you, are indeed still yuliskov, and not some malicious actor?

I will address all of these points in a public, transparent disclosure. My current priority is preparing the final release and pushing it to F-Droid, after which I will immediately publish the statement. Thank you for raising these important questions.

yuliskov avatar Nov 29 '25 18:11 yuliskov

yes, you can keep it unless the PlayProtection is on. And don't forget to backup the data to easily move to the new one Regards, Yuriy

So we're just going to ignore being transparent what happened with the original signing key?

I for one cannot trust any of the new versions until we can confirm your GitHub account (and Patreon) weren't compromised along with the old digital signature. (And in my eyes, neither should others, if they're sensible about it.)

Please update us with a transparent disclosure on the topic.

1. What happened to the original signing key?

2. Do you know how it got leaked?

3. Do you know when it got leaked?

4. What steps are you taking to assure this won't happen in the future?

5. Can you somehow verify that you, are indeed still yuliskov, and not some malicious actor?

Exactly and why is SmartTube above version 30.19 being flagged on VirusTotal by multiple engines.

ACR-Jeff avatar Nov 29 '25 21:11 ACR-Jeff

Thank you! Can you confirm the stable from this link is 30.56?

Just because under releases, latest stable is 30.48, so maybe this link will download that one.

https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTube/releases

Yes, when I downloaded it, version number was 30.56.

You can always analyse any apk via this site too: https://sisik.eu/apk-tool and look for "versionName" in the output.

HIH

dak151 avatar Nov 30 '25 01:11 dak151

yes, you can keep it unless the PlayProtection is on. And don't forget to backup the data to easily move to the new one

Regards, Yuriy

Does this mean 30.48 is still safe to use? I'm just logged in to the smartube but not logging in to my android tv, maybe that's why my playprotect is not protecting.

kukalikuk avatar Nov 30 '25 04:11 kukalikuk

yes, you can keep it unless the PlayProtection is on. And don't forget to backup the data to easily move to the new one Regards, Yuriy

Does this mean 30.48 is still safe to use? I'm just logged in to the smartube but not logging in to my android tv, maybe that's why my playprotect is not protecting.

Yes. You can stay on it. No user reports about it.

yuliskov avatar Nov 30 '25 04:11 yuliskov

With the new version 30.56, I am unable to restore my backup from Google Drive. Is anyone else experiencing the same issue?

crafty991 avatar Nov 30 '25 18:11 crafty991

With the new version 30.56, I am unable to restore my backup from Google Drive. Is anyone else experiencing the same issue?

I saw a comment that said restore succeeded after multiple tries. Can't confirm, as I'm sticking with an old version for a while.

HulkSmashBurgers avatar Nov 30 '25 18:11 HulkSmashBurgers

I haven't tried a Google Drive restore, but I was able to do a local restore successfully.

That said, you might want to strongly consider 1) not using any recent version of the app and 2) disconnect your Google account from it entirely, just to be safe https://github.com/yuliskov/SmartTube/issues/5131#issuecomment-3592402810 (though it sounds like it may be safe to re-install an older, uninfected version and reconnect your account to that, but everything is a bit unknown at this point still).

davidlav avatar Nov 30 '25 19:11 davidlav

I haven't tried a Google Drive restore, but I was able to do a local restore successfully.

That said, you might want to strongly consider 1) not using any recent version of the app and 2) disconnect your Google account from it entirely, just to be safe #5131 (comment) (though it sounds like it may be safe to re-install an older, uninfected version and reconnect your account to that, but everything is a bit unknown at this point still).

Where can I find an older version of the app?

crafty991 avatar Nov 30 '25 19:11 crafty991

With the new version 30.56, I am unable to restore my backup from Google Drive. Is anyone else experiencing the same issue?

I saw a comment that said restore succeeded after multiple tries. Can't confirm, as I'm sticking with an old version for a while.

Sfter the first restore, it had my account logged in, but the settings were still defaut. After a second restore everything was fine.

This was the same on both of my devices.

ErnieBall avatar Nov 30 '25 20:11 ErnieBall

Ok people of Ethernet, which version is SAFE TO INSTALL ?? I GET CONFUSED.

qpman87 avatar Nov 30 '25 21:11 qpman87

With the new version 30.56, I am unable to restore my backup from Google Drive. Is anyone else experiencing the same issue?

It worked on my side. I think someone mentioned restoring 2 times in s row

musicadi avatar Nov 30 '25 22:11 musicadi

Ok people of Ethernet, which version is SAFE TO INSTALL ?? I GET CONFUSED.

Apparently the one from the official site.

https://smarttubeapp.github.io/

musicadi avatar Nov 30 '25 22:11 musicadi

Ok people of Ethernet, which version is SAFE TO INSTALL ?? I GET CONFUSED.

I'd recommend you steer clear of any version until the dust settles and the dev has made an official transparency disclosure and we can actually confirm that that disclosure was posted by the actual dev.

codevogel avatar Nov 30 '25 22:11 codevogel