yii-bootstrap5
yii-bootstrap5 copied to clipboard
yiisoft
Remove prefix `yii-` from `yii-bootstrap5`
If we do it, then need make optional dependencies for Yii Assets and etc. Also need improve readme.
By fact, this package contain widgets, that generate HTML for Bootstrap 5. With this positioning prefix "yii-" not need.
the other packages do not use the "yii-" prefix. Why make an exception to the general pattern?
the other packages do not use the "yii-" prefix. Why make an exception to the general pattern?
Some packages are used yii-prefix. See docs: https://github.com/yiisoft/docs/blob/master/000-packages.md#yii-specific-packages-framework-and-extensions
so it should at least be yii1 yii2 or yii3, because, for me at least, it creates a lot of confusion and headaches having to figure out who is what, including because the yii3 documentation for bootstrap5 is a copy of 4, which makes me wonder that is out of date or the package has not changed at all.
but look at the image and imagine being new or a developer returning after a long time. see the first and last package in the image. Do you realize that we need to look for which version each package belongs to and, in this case, you need to look inside the folder for something that identifies it?
I just want to say that there are simple things that make things a lot easier. And I will read all yii3 packages and report everything that can be improved. And I don't even know Yii... but I believe in it and that it will be released in November this year. and I really want to convert my application to it. That's why I'm trying hard to learn.
why not name everything from version 3 "yii3-"? for version 2 they did this (look at the image), Just a humble suggestion.
Sorry for interfering in the matter without being invited.
It would be great to be able to define it, if we rename it to yii3-bootstrap5 it makes sense, or just bootstrap5, but in general terms the package depends on other yii packages, so i would vote for yii3-bootstrap5.
@terabytesoftw no other Yii3 packages follow yii3-* naming, so either we should adjust them all or use naming that's similar to the ones already released. I'd vote for not changing existing released package names.
Yes, we have conflict in names with Yii1 packages: both packages use names "yii-". But all Yii1 packages with "yii-" names is abandoned and marked as read only.
So, I suggest keep our convention and use "yii-" prefix for Yii3 specific packages.
But as for this package, I think we should rename it to "yiisoft/bootstrap5", because this package provides widgets, that generate HTML for Bootstrap 5. It's not Yii3 specific.