frc-docs icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
frc-docs copied to clipboard

Correct FRC acronym branding

Open Kevin-OConnor opened this issue 5 years ago • 18 comments

The registered trademark symbol should be added to the first use of the FRC acronym in body text on any page where it appears.

This can be accomplished by using

..include:: <isonum.txt> at the top of the document and the using FRC\ |reg| at the first usage of the acronym

Kevin-OConnor avatar Oct 08 '19 15:10 Kevin-OConnor

There should be a space between .. and include: .. include:: <isonum.txt>

sciencewhiz avatar Oct 12 '19 19:10 sciencewhiz

Are there areas where this is still needed? Can someone do a grep?

Daltz333 avatar Sep 29 '20 02:09 Daltz333

(Checking acronym formatting would be a great candidate for a check in CI. It could also check all of the other acronyms that we use)

AustinShalit avatar Sep 29 '20 12:09 AustinShalit

I think that would be best as part of a formatter. #228

Daltz333 avatar Sep 29 '20 15:09 Daltz333

So what all does this apply to. I see: FIRST FRC any others? (I would imagine it could (maybe should) apply to: Microsoft, NI, Axis, CTRE, Vex, etc.

jasondaming avatar Dec 06 '20 18:12 jasondaming

what about the FRC Game Manual at the top of every page? I assume that needs it too?

jasondaming avatar Dec 06 '20 18:12 jasondaming

does frc-docs need to have it also?

jasondaming avatar Dec 06 '20 18:12 jasondaming

frc-docs is creative commons with limitations. Additionally the acronym is only required in certain contexts.

Daltz333 avatar Dec 06 '20 19:12 Daltz333

Note that the ..include:: <isonum.txt> mentioned above will not work. There must be a space between .. and include

jasondaming avatar Dec 06 '20 19:12 jasondaming

FRC® is the former name and it should appear as little as possible in official use. According to the FIRST Branding, it should be written out as FIRST® Robotics Competition, not FRC.

ofekashery avatar Dec 10 '20 08:12 ofekashery

That's not really feasible for us. @Kevin-OConnor can you confirm

Daltz333 avatar Dec 10 '20 08:12 Daltz333

Yes, we are trying to minimize use of the acronym, why is it not feasible?

Kevin-OConnor avatar Dec 10 '20 19:12 Kevin-OConnor

  1. We probably don't want translators to translate it
  2. Seems to add a lot of extra verbosity. Can we use FRC in titles? Or should we just avoid using FRC/FIRST Robotics Competition at all in titles.

Daltz333 avatar Dec 10 '20 20:12 Daltz333

I currently count 1514 uses of FRC in the docs. Not to mention all of the Titles and such it would legthen immensely. That counts links too so it isn't really that high...but it is a lot

jasondaming avatar Dec 10 '20 20:12 jasondaming

We can do it, but it'd be a long term thing to work toward. I think an appropriate short-term solution would be added a notice to the style guide to avoid FRC/FIRST Robotics Competition in titles, and use FIRST Robotics Competition as we go, updating references in documents that are updated. Or we could use the spell-checker to warn on updated documentation to update.

Daltz333 avatar Dec 10 '20 20:12 Daltz333

I agree, I am not suggesting we just Find/Replace it as that will add a ton of length. I think it is a longer term trying to rephrase things to say it less if they're being touched anyway kind of thing.

Kevin-OConnor avatar Dec 10 '20 20:12 Kevin-OConnor

I think the following will close this issue:

  1. Add a notice to the style guide to use FIRST Robotics Competition and not FRC. Do not use either in titles.
  2. Add someway (Github actions check) to flag certain spellings of words (FRC) and to use alternative. Perhaps a tool like wpiformat. A simple python script in scripts would be fine.

Daltz333 avatar Dec 10 '20 20:12 Daltz333

Yep, that sounds reasonable

Kevin-OConnor avatar Dec 10 '20 20:12 Kevin-OConnor