WordPress-iOS icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
WordPress-iOS copied to clipboard

Reader: Portrait Reader Images Cropped Too Much

Open dzver opened this issue 10 months ago • 3 comments

Cropping portrait images is not a great idea when humans are on the photo. It usually cuts the heads off.

dzver avatar Jan 30 '25 13:01 dzver

Thanks for reporting! 👍

dangermattic avatar Jan 30 '25 13:01 dangermattic

Similar scenarios happens in details: https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/7f47b57f-be5c-4ab0-91fe-8c4fd29ac817.

It works as designed as covers have a required aspect ratio on both mobile and web. Mistakes bound to happen, but unfortunately, cropping happens too often as Reader displays random images from the post as covers https://github.com/wordpress-mobile/WordPress-iOS/issues/24045. There are some clear issues with the current system.

kean avatar Feb 27 '25 14:02 kean

There's an ongoing discussion to fix that in the web Reader by not cropping images and using max-height to restrict how tall they can be. I personally think portrait photos should be displayed properly. Cutting people's heads and feet to fit the design is not great.

dzver avatar Apr 24 '25 06:04 dzver