wire-android_legacy icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
wire-android_legacy copied to clipboard

Archived conversations appear on sharing list

Open fllp opened this issue 7 years ago • 3 comments

The problem

Archived conversations are listed like regular ones when sharing contents to wire (in the 'share to' view).

Environment

  • Wire version that exhibits the issue: 3.3.374
  • Last Wire version that did not exhibit the issue (if applicable): n/a
  • Android OS version used to run Wire: 7.1.2
  • Is this a custom firmware or a stock one: custom
  • Mobile phone model/manufacturer: n/a
  • Mobile network type (EDGE/LTE/Wi-Fi/Offline): n/a

Details

Share anything via the android sharing menu. Select Wire as sharing target. List of conversations including archived ones appears.

fllp avatar Nov 28 '17 23:11 fllp

Hi, thanks for getting in touch. We think that archived conversations should appear when sharing content to Wire -- just because you archived them doesn't mean that you don't want to ever talk to those people again, right? Can I ask why you would expect a different behaviour?

someoneEsle avatar Nov 29 '17 07:11 someoneEsle

Oh I see. Well, intuitively I'd have thought archived conversations are those I want to keep for certain reasons but don't write to anymore. A simple example would be, say, an organisational group (birthday present for somebody, holiday with friends). Once the event is organised I might want to keep the messages of the conversation but not write anything more. So at least to me, treating archived convs like regular ones seems a bit counterintuitive. ~~Especially, if the conversation won't get unarchived once I do share some content to it.~~

So, I hope this is a valid use case. If you don't agree, maybe it would help to mark archived conversations somehow in the 'share to' list so one won't unarchive a conversation by accidentally sharing something to it.

fllp avatar Dec 01 '17 13:12 fllp

I find this is the case even for group conversations whose content has been deleted, not just archived. Deleted group chats should certainly not remain on the sharing list. Unfortunately I have someone in my contacts who keeps adding me to groups without my consent (why, oh why, can't Wire ask for consent to join a group?), and my share list is getting polluted with all these deleted group chats.

derkommutator avatar Sep 15 '20 06:09 derkommutator