whipper icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
whipper copied to clipboard

Store genres from MusicBrainz

Open Freso opened this issue 7 years ago • 3 comments

Next release of MusicBrainz will have genre support. An example can be seen at https://beta.musicbrainz.org/release-group/3bd76d40-7f0e-36b7-9348-91a33afee20e (JSON web service output: https://beta.musicbrainz.org/ws/2/release-group/3bd76d40-7f0e-36b7-9348-91a33afee20e?fmt=json&inc=genres )

Should whipper try and get these genres and save them during the rip? Or is that too much bloat?

Freso avatar Oct 16 '18 10:10 Freso

As a user, I think that is too much bloat. Genres are quite subjective, especially in contrast to all other data MusicBrainz provides (release dates, authors, titles, etc.). I think this is best left to a third-party tagger, such as Picard which can efficiently work with MusicBrainz data.

adrienbeau avatar Oct 17 '18 13:10 adrienbeau

I think it would be a neat feature to have. It probably won't add that much code. Don't feel strongly about it, but genres being subjective is not something that worries me that much.

MerlijnWajer avatar Oct 21 '18 16:10 MerlijnWajer

Don't feel strongly about it

JoeLametta avatar Oct 27 '18 14:10 JoeLametta