whipper icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
whipper copied to clipboard

set cd speed to something different from max

Open sp31415t1 opened this issue 7 years ago • 10 comments

I will appreciate to have the option to choose the cd speed to a lower value than my max cd speed. rip will take more time but that's not really an issue.

sp31415t1 avatar Nov 03 '17 20:11 sp31415t1

I think this is a good idea.

RecursiveForest avatar Nov 06 '17 00:11 RecursiveForest

Just wondering, what is the use case here? Percieved accuracy?

MerlijnWajer avatar Feb 01 '18 15:02 MerlijnWajer

maybe better rip on damaged media. for sure, less noise while ripping (I can wait a bit longer, if it is more comfortable for me)

sp31415t1 avatar Feb 01 '18 20:02 sp31415t1

I do not think the speed makes a difference in accuracy - does anyone know if it does? The 'less noise' argument makes sense, but the accuracy I am not so sure of.

MerlijnWajer avatar Feb 01 '18 20:02 MerlijnWajer

I have some media that are a "damaged", but I didn't try the speed impact on quality rip. At 8x or 4x, It is quite silent. At 32x, it is a pain. My computer is semi-fanless (fans are activated only when too hot, hdd vibration are neutralized). The only device producing noise is optical drive at full speed. Nowadays it is almost an optional device.

sp31415t1 avatar Feb 01 '18 20:02 sp31415t1

@JoeLametta - there's a PR for this out. What do you think?

MerlijnWajer avatar Feb 01 '18 23:02 MerlijnWajer

I can't comment on whether it makes a difference to the accuracy of a rip.

My use-case would be to reduce the noise and heat generated, and maybe also to increase the life of the drives. I'm trying to mechanically automate my rips, so reliability is more important to me than raw speed.

calumchisholm avatar Feb 02 '18 01:02 calumchisholm

Just wondering, what is the use case here? Percieved accuracy?

Don't know if the drive speed actually has an impact on the ripping accuracy but it may be true: DAE Quality.

@JoeLametta - there's a PR for this out. What do you think?

Sorry: can't review it right right now. Will certainly have enough time next weekend, hopefully before...

JoeLametta avatar Feb 02 '18 09:02 JoeLametta

I will try to look later this week, if I forget, please just poke us/me.

MerlijnWajer avatar Feb 05 '18 12:02 MerlijnWajer

Issue blocked on #244.

JoeLametta avatar Nov 12 '18 08:11 JoeLametta