web-scrobbler icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
web-scrobbler copied to clipboard

Force scrobble for excluded Youtube video categories

Open tsukijin opened this issue 5 years ago • 8 comments

Expected behavior

Instead of having youtube videos not being scrobbled at all if they're in a different category than Music or Entertainment there should be an optional button to force scrobbling for the currently playing video. Which would then whitelist that video so that you don't have to force scrobbling every time, similar to the edited tracks feature.

Current behavior

Videos in excluded categories are cast into the shadow realm, never to be scrobbled again. There are a lot of songs that are uploaded by negligent people who put the videos in the wrong categories.

Context

I would also rather not have the Entertainment category scrobbled because, like most people, I use Youtube for more than just music and so I don't want to scrobble a bunch of random youtube videos to my last.fm account obviously lol

tsukijin avatar Oct 24 '18 02:10 tsukijin

How would this work? have some ability from the menu bar to force a scrobble?

inverse avatar Nov 03 '18 19:11 inverse

have some ability from the menu bar to force a scrobble?

yes, exactly. my idea was basically like this: vaml

tsukijin avatar Nov 03 '18 19:11 tsukijin

I'd very much like the ability to force scrobbling for specific youtube videos. I run into the scenario that OP wrote up all the time, where a music video has clearly been placed into the wrong category.

mwgamble avatar Feb 05 '19 22:02 mwgamble

Same here. example definitely soundtrack. But it's Gaming category. There's no option to allow scrobble from gaming side-by-side with music category filter and forbid others. Should i start separate issue?

non-descriptive avatar Jan 14 '20 10:01 non-descriptive

@non-descriptive no, it's related to this issue.

alexesprit avatar Jan 14 '20 11:01 alexesprit

The possible solution is to mark excluded videos as skipped (we already do this for podcasts), and implement a feature to continue ("unskip") skipped songs.

This requires some reorganizations in core and content scripts.

alexesprit avatar May 03 '20 10:05 alexesprit

I'd also really like this feature. I've encountered quite a few official music videos that have been poorly categorised and thus don't scrobble.

Scrobbling everything I watch on YouTube (and then manually deleting the non-music) is a very clunky solution.

Thesaurus-saurus avatar Jun 06 '21 23:06 Thesaurus-saurus

Expected behavior

Instead of having youtube videos not being scrobbled at all if they're in a different category than Music or Entertainment there should be an optional button to force scrobbling for the currently playing video. Which would then whitelist that video so that you don't have to force scrobbling every time, similar to the edited tracks feature.

Current behavior

Videos in excluded categories are cast into the shadow realm, never to be scrobbled again. There are a lot of songs that are uploaded by negligent people who put the videos in the wrong categories.

Context

I would also rather not have the Entertainment category scrobbled because, like most people, I use Youtube for more than just music and so I don't want to scrobble a bunch of random youtube videos to my last.fm account obviously lol

I couldn't agree more with this!

mirKu29 avatar Aug 26 '21 21:08 mirKu29

Partially implemented without whitelisting feature by #4104

yayuyokitano avatar Sep 23 '23 13:09 yayuyokitano