interop-accessibility icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
interop-accessibility copied to clipboard

Confirm, remove, or modify tbody, thead, tfoot role tests

Open nmlapre opened this issue 1 year ago • 3 comments

Three tests in html-aam/table-roles.html (el-thead, el-tbody, and el-tfoot) are failing on all tested browsers. There is an open spec issue aiming to find a way forward, but there's no consensus solution yet. Given that these tests are included in interop-2024, I think we should decide whether we want to:

  • keep them as-is,
  • move them to .tentative files, or
  • modify them (e.g., make the elements focusable or give them labels to force accessible node creation)

Based on how we've been handling other similar unresolved spec issues, I think I lean towards moving the tests to a tentative file for 2024, though I think @jcsteh's suggestion here is also reasonable.

nmlapre avatar May 14 '24 21:05 nmlapre

Given the challenge, we can move them to tentative immediately, and wait for spec resolution/implementation to bring them back in after Interop 2024. If you write the PR, I can review it. Thanks.

cookiecrook avatar May 22 '24 19:05 cookiecrook

(I can also write the PR, but I'm OOO for an indeterminate amount of time so my WPT time is limited.)

cookiecrook avatar May 22 '24 19:05 cookiecrook

No worries, I'll write the PR. All the best to you - thanks.

nmlapre avatar May 22 '24 19:05 nmlapre

Back in the office today. PR approved assuming you accept the proposed diff. Thanks for authoring it.

cookiecrook avatar Jun 14 '24 07:06 cookiecrook