polkadot-wiki icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
polkadot-wiki copied to clipboard

Add more bidding examples for Parachain slot auctions

Open DrW3RK opened this issue 2 years ago • 1 comments

https://wiki.polkadot.network/docs/learn-auction#examples

From Bill

I would put in a few more examples - what happens if Emily and Dave win (they split the parachain slot for the two different lease ranges), and what happens if Frank (or some other "F" name) bids 1000 DOT and wins, but only for range 1 -2, and nobody bids for any LPs 3 - 8. Or if Frank bids 1000 DOT for range 1 - 2, and someone else bids 50 DOT for range 1 - 8, and those are the only bids.

Add more examples like above, probably by citing a real auction bid scenario

image

DrW3RK avatar Apr 14 '22 07:04 DrW3RK

I might be missing something important (apologize). Below a few thoughts/examples (also inspired by the comments above).

I start with the same example from https://wiki.polkadot.network/docs/learn-auction#examples:

Example 1 (C = Charlie wins all 8 slots): auction.pdf

Example 2 (a new bidder F = Frank joins and beats C, but only wants the last 4 slots): auction2.pdf Now the first 4 slots are ``free'' (Charlie does not win anymore) and they can be assigned to D = Dave: auction2.1.pdf

Example 3 (both Dave and Emily have rather high valuations for their respective intervals, so that they jointly beat Charlie): auction3.pdf It may be possible that (with these valuations) Dave may get better (lower) price by bidding less, still enough to win jointly with Emily (their sum exceed 600 = Charlie's bid): auction3.1.pdf During the auction, Dave may face the following dilemma: bid less than the true valuation (100 x 4 = 400) hoping that someone will join the auction for some of the last 4 slots, in order to ``kick out'' Charlie auction4.pdf

The tendency/temptation to underbid (report less than the true valuations) during the auction is counterbalanced by the ``candle mechanism'', that is, not knowing when exactly the auction will end, it exposes Dave to the risk of loosing the slots (I think).

paolo-penna avatar May 25 '22 10:05 paolo-penna