w3process icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
w3process copied to clipboard

Link to document on formal objection processing

Open samuelweiler opened this issue 6 years ago • 3 comments

Add an in-line informative reference to: https://www.w3.org/2017/12/formal-objections.html

(Alternatively, deprecate that document.)

samuelweiler avatar Oct 30 '19 18:10 samuelweiler

astonishingly, the process says nothing at all about processing FOs, only about recording and reporting them. We probably need a short section somewhere.

I'd rather not deprecate; when we go Dir-Free, we'll need an improved version of this.

dwsinger avatar Jun 29 '20 23:06 dwsinger

For Director-free, the AB has been working on a draft improved version of this: https://www.w3.org/2019/06/W3C%20Council%20guidelines%20for%20formal-objections.html

jeffjaffe avatar Jun 30 '20 00:06 jeffjaffe

@samuelweiler, The whole handling of formal objections is being reconsidered, in order to figure out how to make it work in a director-free w3c. In the present state of things, the suggestion you're making here seems reasonable, but I am not sure we want to draw attention to things that are about to change, so I'd rather defer this issue. Are you ok with that?

frivoal avatar May 10 '21 05:05 frivoal

Closing as out of scope in favor of https://github.com/w3c/Guide/issues/166

frivoal avatar Sep 23 '22 00:09 frivoal