clreq icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
clreq copied to clipboard

sup in ruby?

Open OverflowCat opened this issue 1 year ago • 2 comments

https://github.com/w3c/clreq/issues/536#issuecomment-1573376429

粤拼可能不值得单独提出来讨论,但它可以作为一个有代表性的使用数字作为声调的拼音系统。是否需要明确,不管是在正文中还是 <ruby> 中,这些声调有时要作为上标?

Jyutping, while perhaps not warranting extensive separate discussion, is a representative system that employs numerals to represent tones. Should it be explicitly stated, either in normal text or within <ruby> annotations, that these tone numbers are sometimes superscripted?

例:

Examples:

Image

https://mrpen.hk/%E7%B2%B5%E8%AA%9E%E5%AD%97

Image

https://x.com/jkwchui/status/1766373416406585648

cc @xfq

OverflowCat avatar Jan 26 '25 00:01 OverflowCat

我和侯兴泉老师发表的文章《粤方言拼音方案概说》(《南方语言学》第二十一辑,p70—86)提到了粤拼(我们称为“香港方案”)的“声调应为其原形而不推荐使用上标或下标”(p80)。这是香港语言学学会自己的重申,在文章撰写期间也和香港语言学学会确认过这一原则。张群显老师和其他作者一起撰写的粤剧读物《〈帝女花〉读本》《〈紫钗记〉读本》都用的是上标的声调,但这不是他的本意。我们文章里还提到“广州方案”的声调应是上标(p76)。

eisoch avatar Jan 28 '25 12:01 eisoch

那么,其他拼音方案中出现的是否值得提及呢?

So, are the ones that appear in other romanizations worth mentioning?

OverflowCat avatar Mar 31 '25 07:03 OverflowCat