NotepadEx icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
NotepadEx copied to clipboard

Add the possibility of not using Vista/7 features in versions higher than Windows XP

Open OrthodoxWindows opened this issue 11 months ago • 5 comments

Among these functionalities, I do not see any improvement, but rather regressions. It's all about these three features :

  • The task dialogs
  • The new-style file dialogs
  • The new-style windows help

The "do you want to save" prompt is problematic with the classic theme. If I use the original version of Windows XP, I get this (on modern Windows) :

notepad_ea8KJ74bnM

With the new "do you want to save" prompt, I get this :

npex64(1)_T4Frw9yAbk

There is a big problem with the size of the buttons. The ability to use the old version would be great.

Regarding the new-style file dialogs, I don't have a preference, but some users prefer the old style, because the dialog loads faster.

Finally, I find that the new style of Windows help is less efficient than the old one, because it requires an internet connection, whereas the old one did not. I would also greatly appreciate the possibility of restoring the old one.

In any case, thank you very much for this project.

OrthodoxWindows avatar Jul 26 '23 10:07 OrthodoxWindows

There appears to be an issue with your Windows because the task dialogs seem to appear fine when I enable classic theme.

image

Do any other task dialogs from other applications have the issue? Are you running a high DPI display (or have Windows font/UI scaling set to anything other than 100%)?

Regardless, I will add either a settings menu or some registry options you can set to get the old style dialog. This will be present in the next release. Thanks for your feedback.

vxiiduu avatar Jul 26 '23 13:07 vxiiduu

Thank you for your reply.

In fact, I'm in Windows 10, all dialogs of this type display badly with the classic theme on this system, it's a known problem. This also happens in Windows 10 notepad. It's just not very annoying because not many programs use this dialog box. Otherwise my system is at 100% DPI.

I actually think that including in the registry the possibility of restoring the old task dialogs is a good idea. The ideal would be to include the possibility of restoring the old windows help in the same way.

OrthodoxWindows avatar Jul 26 '23 14:07 OrthodoxWindows

Classic theme does not exist in Windows 10 without mods the buttons display correctly on W7 with classic theme, so i don't think vxiiduu can fix an issue caused by custom theming

tho i do agree a registry switch for old dialogs on post XP could be interesting + pepole can still import the help files from XP and use them

MiraakThuri avatar Aug 02 '23 15:08 MiraakThuri

Yes, you summed it up pretty well. Indeed, I do not ask for more than the registry key. Regarding the help file, I'm talking about the link to the file, in the help menu. Importing an offline help file does not change the pointing to the Microsoft site in the help menu.

OrthodoxWindows avatar Aug 02 '23 15:08 OrthodoxWindows

This Windhawk mod can fix task dialog buttons on Windows 10.

aubymori avatar Oct 29 '23 20:10 aubymori