crash space add more then 40000 shapes

[zipandrar]

this is a example source.py

crashTest.zip

#when the num is 30000 it work well #when the num is more than 40000 or 100000, it will get crashed in the line space.add(body, shape) #is it a bug or memeroy not enough??? but i think no one need more than 30000 bodies or shapes....

#i like pymunk.... ... in my test ,it is about 10x faster than pybox2d... ...

#faster and clear.... thanks to all of chipmunk's developers and thanks to all of pymunk's developers...

[viblo]

Thanks for the report! Which version of pymunk, python and what OS do you use? I tried myself and got crashes on CPython 2.7 32 and 64bit and CPython 3.7 on Windows, but on CPython 2.7 64bits on Ubuntu I cant get it to crash.

[zipandrar]

win7_64bit Cpython2.7.10_32bit pymunk_5.3.2

hmmm.so it is a memory problem.... it very very enough with 30000 shapes too....

[viblo]

Lets keep this open a bit, just to keep track of it while I test a bit more. It seems to only happen for static and kinematic bodies, not dynamic ones. And the exception happens inside the chipmunk library code, in the cpArrayContains function.

[viblo]

An update to this: I did some more investigation of this old ticket, and it turns out that nowadays its stack overflow in the spatial tree that causes error. I have reported it to the Chipmunk issue tracker, but given how slow that project moves nowadays I dont expect a fix soon.

There is a workaround, use the spatial hash instead (space.use_spatial_hash(...)). Using this I could not get it to crash as easily.

If you or someone else has a proper use case which this crash prevents I can take another look, otherwise I think I wont try too hard to make a fix..