vgstation13 icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
vgstation13 copied to clipboard

In-Game PR Voting

Open N3X15 opened this issue 6 years ago • 7 comments

We need an in-game system for voting on non-WIP PRs. A good system would utilize github's API to build a list of active PRs with links to a more detailed page, and provide merge/no-merge/no opinion buttons.

I'm currently up to my neck in other projects, so don't plan on doing this myself.

Benefits

  • Players wouldn't need a github account to vote
  • This would replace emojiocracy with a more accurate and less-abusable system
  • Would hopefully reduce the amount of shitposting on github

Detriments

  • Players would need a github account to comment
  • Would require checking the voting system before merging
    • Maybe add a pre-merge check?
  • Drawing up policies
  • Drama

[featurerequest][controversial][system][ui]

N3X15 avatar Nov 23 '19 19:11 N3X15

Maybe we need more PR awareness? TG has the whole "announce new, merged or closed PRs in the chat" thing

boy2mantwicethefam avatar Nov 23 '19 19:11 boy2mantwicethefam

remember when they also announced created PRs and people used to it to make "IT'S MALF" PRs

jknpj avatar Nov 23 '19 19:11 jknpj

Maybe have a list of active PRs in the pregame lobby as something to browse while you're waiting?

Blithering avatar Nov 26 '19 16:11 Blithering

TG had a similar system, in which PRs were announced on their server. Someone used it to ick-ock from the github.

ShiftyRail avatar Nov 28 '19 20:11 ShiftyRail

Well it's a good thing we have a far higher quality of player than TG

As for voting from in game I feel like that bare minimum amount of effort required to do it right now is a good way for ensuring people put some thought into what they are doing

tuypo1 avatar Nov 29 '19 07:11 tuypo1

Kinda why I thought the pregame lobby would be better than mid round, the worst we'll get is "Ready up for cult"

Blithering avatar Nov 29 '19 13:11 Blithering

the d3athrow-issues account could probably get around the comment issue, with checks to ban ckeys from using it if need be

SECBATON-GRIFFON avatar Oct 07 '24 16:10 SECBATON-GRIFFON