landscape icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
landscape copied to clipboard

groups: Can't join group

Open basilesportif opened this issue 3 years ago • 12 comments

Describe the bug When I'm invited to a group, clicking the Accept button in notifications does nothing.

To Reproduce Steps to reproduce the behavior:

  1. Invite a user you control to a group you own
  2. Log on to that user's Urbit
  3. go to Notifications
  4. try to click Accept
  5. observe nothing happens

Operating context

  • Device: laptop
  • OS: Ubuntu 20.04
  • Browser: Brave
  • Landscape Version: Groups 1.0.4

basilesportif avatar Dec 09 '21 13:12 basilesportif

Have you refreshed the page? If you have the new JS bundle, then the an invite should be visible in the list of group tiles, with blue text saying invited

liam-fitzgerald avatar Dec 09 '21 22:12 liam-fitzgerald

OK seems like what was happening is that the group was being joined in the background when I clicked "Accept" in notifications, but that didn't clear the Accept/Dismiss dialog, so it was confusing.

basilesportif avatar Dec 10 '21 07:12 basilesportif

Relates to urbit/landscape#1038

jamesacklin avatar Jan 06 '22 19:01 jamesacklin

I've been unable to join groups with my star or planet for about 6 months now. Hi guys!

tylershuster avatar Jan 20 '22 20:01 tylershuster

@tylershuster We miss you!

jamesacklin avatar Jan 21 '22 22:01 jamesacklin

Fixed by urbit/urbit#5536

jamesacklin avatar Jan 26 '22 15:01 jamesacklin

This fixed the modal for me, but it doesn't actually fix my issue joining groups

tylershuster avatar Jan 29 '22 17:01 tylershuster

@tylershuster Which groups? You can also DM me at ~rilfun-lidlen if you're not comfortable sharing. We're currently looking at ~bitbet-bolbel.

jamesacklin avatar Jan 30 '22 01:01 jamesacklin

Er, any of them. ~paldev/group and U-C have been my tests. I can DM you when I get home, or feel free to reach out on the network

T

On Jan 29, 2022, at 5:47 PM, nerveharp @.***> wrote:

 @tylershuster Which groups? You can also DM me at ~rilfun-lidlen if you're not comfortable sharing. We're currently looking at ~bitbet-bolbel.

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe. You are receiving this because you were mentioned.

tylershuster avatar Jan 30 '22 01:01 tylershuster

A desync issue from @tylershuster:

out=[acked=%.y path=/resource/ver/ship/~paldev/group/0]
subscribe wire not unique
%group-pull-hook
/helper/pull-hook/pull/resource/ship/~paldev/group
[p=~paldev q=%group-push-hook]
error in %group-pull-hook
%watch-not-unique
! subscribe wire not un~radbur-sivmus:dojo> ique
! %group-pull-hook
! /helper/pull-hook/pull/resource/ship/~paldev/group
! [p=~paldev q=%group-push-hook]
; ~matber is ok
[%missing-subscription-in-unsubscribe '1643585763-cf9447' 67]
[%e %authenticated-without-cookie]
; ~matber not responding still trying
~radbur-sivmus:dojo> 

Noisy fix is running the following in the dojo:

:group-pull-hook +kick, =nice |

jamesacklin avatar Feb 22 '22 21:02 jamesacklin

I'm seeing what seems to be related to this, and have not seen any change in behavior when running :group-pull-hook +kick, =nice | so far.

Joining most groups has worked so far, but I haven't been able to make it past "Retrieving members" on ~bitbet-bolbel /urbit-community, the-forge, or a couple of other small (below 100 member) groups. I do seem to be getting data from the ships, but most responses back with |ames-verb %rcv are returning "hear last dupe" results. Behavior is the same in each failed case: I can connect to the host, but can't ever finish joining the group.

image image

divdus-tarnus avatar Mar 12 '22 05:03 divdus-tarnus

Checking in to see if this has been addressed

tylershuster avatar May 26 '22 16:05 tylershuster