developers.urbit.org icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
developers.urbit.org copied to clipboard

%aqua guide instructions broken

Open drbeefsupreme opened this issue 4 years ago • 4 comments

There's an oldish guide (2 years I think?) for %aqua at https://urbit.org/docs/hoon/guides/aqua

I tried following the directions:

|start %aqua
:aqua +solid
-ph-add

but it doesn't get all the way through.

gall: installing %aqua
> |start %aqua
>=
%solid-start
%solid-loaded
%solid-parsed
%solid-arvo
[%solid-kernel 0x7168.4d12]
lull: ~hidrun-loclun
zuse: ~tipnut-hacpyl
vane %ames: ~rigsud-bolmes
vane %behn: ~sartes-masnyl
vane %clay: ~dachut-hapdur
vane %dill: ~milwer-fogmeb
vane %eyre: ~bonler-ranteb
vane %gall: ~dildus-landef
vane %iris: ~macryl-midnyl
vane %jael: ~rabbyl-famdeg
[%user-files 397]
> :aqua +solid
/sys/vane/gall/hoon:<[1.372 9].[1.372 37]>
/app/aqua/hoon:<[81 5].[89 17]>
/app/aqua/hoon:<[82 5].[89 17]>
/app/aqua/hoon:<[83 7].[88 9]>
/app/aqua/hoon:<[83 17].[83 45]>
[%aqua-bad-mark %boot-pill]
/app/aqua/hoon:<[83 42].[83 44]>
dojo: app poke failed

Not sure if this is actually a bug with %aqua or something else, or its just outdated. Given the release of software distribution, it might be the right time to rewrite this guide anyways.

drbeefsupreme avatar Dec 08 '21 22:12 drbeefsupreme

Trying the instructions in app/aqua.hoon, :aqua &pill +solid:

%solid-start
%solid-loaded
%solid-parsed
%solid-arvo
[%solid-kernel 0xfa6.fd63]
lull: ~hidrun-loclun
zuse: ~tipnut-hacpyl
vane %ames: ~rigsud-bolmes
vane %behn: ~sartes-masnyl
vane %clay: ~dachut-hapdur
vane %dill: ~milwer-fogmeb
vane %eyre: ~bonler-ranteb
vane %gall: ~dildus-landef
vane %iris: ~macryl-midnyl
vane %jael: ~rabbyl-famdeg
[%user-files 397]
clay: read-at-aeon fail [desk=%base care=%c case=[%da p=~2021.12.8..22.29.27..6423] path=/boot-pill/pill]
clay: no files match /mar/boot-pill/hoon
[%error-building-cast %boot-pill %pill]
[%error-building-tube %boot-pill %pill]
/sys/vane/clay/hoon:<[4.284 13].[4.284 34]>
/sys/vane/clay/hoon:<[4.271 7].[4.297 9]>
! /sys/vane/gall/hoon:<[1.392 9].[1.392 47]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[1.662 3].[1.671 20]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[1.663 3].[1.671 20]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[1.664 3].[1.671 20]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[1.665 3].[1.671 20]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[1.666 5].[1.670 7]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[1.667 5].[1.670 7]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[1.668 25].[1.668 62]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[1.067 5].[1.076 7]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[1.068 5].[1.076 7]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[1.069 5].[1.076 7]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[1.070 5].[1.076 7]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[1.072 7].[1.075 60]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[1.075 7].[1.075 60]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[488 7].[490 67]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[489 7].[490 67]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[490 7].[490 67]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[978 7].[984 46]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[979 7].[984 46]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[980 7].[984 46]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[982 7].[984 46]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[984 7].[984 46]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[895 7].[932 9]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[896 7].[932 9]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[897 7].[932 9]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[898 7].[932 9]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[903 16].[903 62]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[872 7].[872 22]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[494 7].[497 37]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[497 7].[497 37]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[488 7].[490 67]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[489 7].[490 67]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[490 7].[490 67]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[978 7].[984 46]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[979 7].[984 46]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[980 7].[984 46]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[982 7].[984 46]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[984 7].[984 46]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[895 7].[932 9]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[896 7].[932 9]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[897 7].[932 9]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[898 7].[932 9]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[909 9].[914 37]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[910 9].[914 37]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[911 9].[914 37]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[913 9].[914 37]>
! /app/dojo/hoon:<[913 13].[913 65]>
! /cc/~bud/base/~2021.12.8..22.29.27..6423/boot-pill/pill
[%dojo-lame %arvo-response]

drbeefsupreme avatar Dec 08 '21 22:12 drbeefsupreme

path=/boot-pill/pill]
clay: no files match /mar/boot-pill/hoon
[%error-building-cast %boot-pill %pill]
[%error-building-tube %boot-pill %pill]

seems like a key part but I can't find boot-pill or %boot %pill or boot/pill anywhere in the repo. Trying to figure out how its getting this mark name.

drbeefsupreme avatar Dec 08 '21 22:12 drbeefsupreme

/gen/solid.hoon and /gen/brass.hoon seemingly return that mark

tinnus-napbus avatar Jan 10 '22 14:01 tinnus-napbus

This problem dates to urbit/urbit#5029 (specifically urbit/urbit@3417927aef1cc8b4044bd1f0a684ce7f67ebf02d, which incompletely rolled back the mark changes from urbit/urbit@61845e605ef8cceb915215a3bc222e62412d3643). I'm not sure why that was merged without final review, but it should be an easy fix.

joemfb avatar Feb 01 '22 03:02 joemfb